Supreme Court Grants Continuity of Services and Back Wages in Retrenchment Case with No Bona Fide Intent
Case Title: ARMED FORCES EX OFFICERS MULTI SERVICES COOPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD. Vs. RASHTRIYA MAZDOOR SANGH
Decided On: AUGUST 11, 2022
Introduction
Welcome to the official blog of the Law Offices of Kr. Vivek Tanwar Advocate and Associates, where we are dedicated to providing litigation support services for matters related to Wrongful Retrenchment. In today’s blog post, we aim to shed light on the prevailing issues surrounding Wrongful Retrenchment, the legal framework for their protection, and the steps we can take as a society to combat these acts. Join us as we explore this critical subject and empower you with the knowledge to protect your rights and safety.
In a significant ruling, the Supreme Court of India recently affirmed the principle that retrenchment does not automatically grant employees continuity of services; it must be followed by a bona fide intent. The lack of bona fide intention by the employer paved the way for the court to award continuity of services and back wages to the affected employees.
Legal Precedent
On August 11, a division bench of the Supreme Court presided over by Justices B.R. Gavai and P.S. Narasimha, delivered a crucial judgment. The court held that if an employer’s retrenchment of employees, followed by an offer of re-employment under new terms, is not conducted in good faith, the retrenchment orders can be annulled, entitling employees to both continuity of service and back wages.
Case Background
- Cooperative offered services like transportation, housekeeping, and security.
- The dispute began with 55 drivers seeking pay raises and permanent employment status.
- Initial conciliation proceedings in 2007, followed by a strike by drivers.
- Cooperative claimed the strike was illegal; the tribunal granted interim relief.
- Drivers returned to work but were retrenched in March 2007, citing business closure.
- Drivers received compensation under Section 25F.
- Rashtriya Mazdoor Sangh filed a complaint, alleging the retrenchment was illegal.
- Cooperative offered to reinstate the drivers during this time.
- In September 2017, the Industrial Tribunal ordered reinstatement, deeming the retrenchment punitive and lacking bona fide intent.
Legal Interpretation
According to Section 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act, ‘retrenchment’ is defined as the employer’s termination of a worker’s service for any reason, except as a disciplinary measure. This definition excludes cases of voluntary retirement, non-renewal of a contract, and similar situations. In this particular instance, the tribunal determined that the termination amounted to a punitive action, casting doubt on the legitimacy of the retrenchment. As a result of the tribunal’s decision, the drivers were reinstated with uninterrupted wages and 75% of their back wages, with the exception of eight drivers who had secured gainful employment after their retrenchment
Challenging the Tribunal’s Decision
The cooperative filed a writ petition in the Bombay High Court challenging the tribunal’s award, and the Rashtriya Mazdoor Sangh also approached the high court to challenge the denial of back wages for the eight drivers. However, the high court upheld the tribunal’s findings. Subsequently, the cooperative appealed the high court’s decision to the Supreme Court.
Supreme Court’s Legal Rationale
- Cooperative presented four arguments countered by the Supreme Court’s division bench, led by Justice Narasimha.
- First argument: The Cooperative claimed illegal strikes by drivers justified contract termination and retrenchment. However, the Supreme Court found the retrenchment resembled a business closure and lacked genuine intent, causing drivers to forfeit accrued benefits.
- Second argument: The Cooperative argued a temporary shutdown for business reorganization. Supreme Court saw it as punitive and unnecessary for the entire business to close due to strikes.
- Third argument: The Cooperative said re-employment was lawful under Section 25H of the Industrial Dispute Act. Supreme Court clarified this rule applied to bona fide retrenchment, which didn’t apply here.
- Fourth argument: The Cooperative questioned the 75% back wages, citing the need for drivers to declare unemployment. Supreme Court deferred to the tribunal’s thorough examination and noted that 27 drivers had confirmed their unemployment post-termination.
Significance of the Judgment
- This ruling carries significant legal consequences for the increasing occurrence of staff reductions and job terminations in the Indian job market, highlighting the necessity of adhering to established procedures. It serves as a cautionary message to employers, urging them to exercise prudence in their employment-related choices.
- Concurrently, the judgment strikes a balance in the relationship between employees and employers, emphasizing that the right to strike is not absolute and can be reasonably constrained by governmental and judicial authorities. This verdict reinforces the principle that retrenchment must be executed in good faith to be legally legitimate.
- At a time when workplace conflicts and workforce reductions are becoming more common, the Supreme Court’s position reinforces the requirement for a just and impartial approach to labor interactions and disputes.
Conclusion
This ruling has profound legal implications for the growing job cuts in the Indian job market, emphasizing the need for adherence to procedures, employer caution, and a balanced employee-employer relationship while reinforcing the importance of fair labor practices during an era of increased employment disputes and layoffs.
We are a law firm in the name and style of Law Offices of Kr. Vivek Tanwar Advocate and Associates at Gurugram and Rewari. We are providing litigation support services for matters related to Wrongful Retrenchment under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
A beacon of excellence in pharmaceutical care.
lisinopril bula
A model pharmacy in terms of service and care.
https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm
http://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm
SemagluPharm: Semaglu Pharm – semaglutide withdrawal symptoms
SemagluPharm buy semaglutide peptides Semaglutide tablets without prescription
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Affordable Rybelsus price
https://lipipharm.com/# lipitor and crestor
lipitor and pregnancy: atorvastatin adverse effects – LipiPharm
LipiPharm Lipi Pharm does atorvastatin cause hair loss
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Order Rybelsus discreetly
SemagluPharm: Semaglu Pharm – rybelsus manufacturer coupon
prednisone buy without prescription Predni Pharm buy prednisone from canada
https://semaglupharm.com/# Buy Rybelsus online USA
https://lipipharm.com/# Lipi Pharm
Predni Pharm: prednisone 10 mg tablet cost – prednisone 50 mg tablet canada
where to get semaglutide near me SemagluPharm is rybelsus safe
https://semaglupharm.shop/# SemagluPharm
Generic Lipitor fast delivery: atorvastatin 40 mg tablet – FDA-approved generic statins online
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Semaglu Pharm
Crestor Pharm will crestor lower triglycerides CrestorPharm
Semaglu Pharm: SemagluPharm – Semaglu Pharm
http://lipipharm.com/# Lipi Pharm
https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm
purchase prednisone generic prednisone cost Predni Pharm
rosuvastatin once a week: Crestor Pharm – Generic Crestor for high cholesterol
http://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm
PredniPharm Predni Pharm prednisone buy
https://semaglupharm.com/# is rybelsus covered by insurance
can you take rybelsus if you are not diabetic: Semaglu Pharm – SemagluPharm
http://prednipharm.com/# order prednisone from canada
Lipi Pharm LipiPharm Lipi Pharm
https://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm
Semaglu Pharm Rybelsus 3mg 7mg 14mg SemagluPharm
https://semaglupharm.shop/# SemagluPharm
SemagluPharm: Affordable Rybelsus price – rybelsus malaysia price
Crestor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg online Best price for Crestor online USA CrestorPharm
https://lipipharm.com/# Cheap Lipitor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg
http://semaglupharm.com/# Where to buy Semaglutide legally
CrestorPharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm
Lipi Pharm lipitor vs lovastatin LipiPharm
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Semaglu Pharm
price of crestor 5mg: CrestorPharm – rosuvastatin 10 mg pill identifier
crestor 5mg tablet is it better to take crestor in the morning or at night Crestor mail order USA
https://semaglupharm.com/# No prescription diabetes meds online
https://prednipharm.com/# prednisone 40 mg rx
india pharmacy: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global
India Pharm Global п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india best online pharmacy india
http://canadapharmglobal.com/# certified canadian international pharmacy
pharmacy in canada: canadian pharmacy antibiotics – canadian pharmacy world
https://canadapharmglobal.com/# thecanadianpharmacy
Meds From Mexico mexican pharmaceuticals online mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://medsfrommexico.com/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
https://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global
India Pharm Global: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global
precription drugs from canada pharmacy canadian superstore buy canadian drugs
https://indiapharmglobal.shop/# India Pharm Global
https://indiapharmglobal.shop/# India Pharm Global
rate canadian pharmacies: pharmacies in canada that ship to the us – canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us
canadian online pharmacy canadian online drugs canada drugs online reviews
https://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
mexican mail order pharmacies: pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa – buying from online mexican pharmacy
canadian family pharmacy Canada Pharm Global canadian pharmacy prices
http://medsfrommexico.com/# best mexican online pharmacies
https://medsfrommexico.shop/# medication from mexico pharmacy
canada drugs online review: Canada Pharm Global – best canadian pharmacy
cheapest online pharmacy india pharmacy website india reputable indian online pharmacy
https://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global
purple pharmacy mexico price list: mexican pharmaceuticals online – mexico drug stores pharmacies
Meds From Mexico buying from online mexican pharmacy Meds From Mexico
https://canadapharmglobal.shop/# ed meds online canada
http://canadapharmglobal.com/# onlinepharmaciescanada com
Meds From Mexico: Meds From Mexico – Meds From Mexico
canadian pharmacy cheap Canada Pharm Global reliable canadian pharmacy
https://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
https://canadapharmglobal.shop/# canadian drug stores
Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – hudorm fjerner apotek
http://efarmaciait.com/# fucicort unguento
https://efarmaciait.shop/# xanax pasticche
katt vitlök överdosering b-vitamin hund apotek självtest
springmask engelska: Svenska Pharma – sura uppstГ¶tningar barn 8 Г¤r
http://raskapotek.com/# Rask Apotek
sweat pads apotek salpetersyre apotek follikulitt apotek
cepillo oral b io: Papa Farma – Papa Farma
https://efarmaciait.shop/# EFarmaciaIt
http://efarmaciait.com/# amoxicillina bustine
tobrex comprar Papa Farma viagra spania
https://raskapotek.com/# salpetersyre apotek
promociГіn braun 100 euros: farmacia del ahorro espaГ±a – brentan crema in english
EFarmaciaIt benu farmacia EFarmaciaIt
http://efarmaciait.com/# EFarmaciaIt
https://efarmaciait.shop/# farmaco online
farmacia online spedizione gratis ryaltris spray a cosa serve EFarmaciaIt
h2 blokker apotek: online apotek – johannesurt apotek
https://efarmaciait.shop/# EFarmaciaIt
Rask Apotek cbd olje sverige apotek apotek +
https://papafarma.shop/# Papa Farma
Papa Farma: Papa Farma – Papa Farma
https://efarmaciait.shop/# diflucan serve ricetta
menstrosa apotek: Svenska Pharma – Svenska Pharma
Papa Farma mabodol crema para que sirve Papa Farma
http://raskapotek.com/# Rask Apotek
https://papafarma.com/# cupon descuento farmacias direct
Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – apotek spania
http://efarmaciait.com/# spray cicatrizzante post parto
Papa Farma Papa Farma comprar cialis espaГ±a
magnesium citrate apotek: Rask Apotek – Rask Apotek
http://efarmaciait.com/# robilas opinioni
Papa Farma Papa Farma farma direct
http://papafarma.com/# Papa Farma
farmacia sin gastos de envio: mycostatin pomada – Papa Farma
https://svenskapharma.com/# Svenska Pharma
permixon acquisto on line betametasone 1 mg prisma compresse 50 mg prezzo
http://papafarma.com/# Papa Farma
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# Pharma Jetzt
http://medicijnpunt.com/# mediceinen
verre Г rhum personnalisГ©: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Jetzt mediherz shop Pharma Jetzt
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# netherlands pharmacy online
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
malaysia viagra pharmacy: Pharma Connect USA – PharmaConnectUSA
http://pharmajetzt.com/# shopapotjeke
PharmaJetzt Pharma Jetzt Pharma Jetzt
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# günstig medikamente bestellen
health rx pharmacy: thrifty drug store – omeprazole pharmacy
Medicijn Punt mijn apotheek online pharmacy
https://pharmajetzt.com/# medikament bestellen
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
apotheke germany: online versandapotheke – Pharma Jetzt
sildenafil pharmacie prix parapharmacie homГ©opathie pharmacies autour de moi
https://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
Pharma Confiance: quand prendre amoxicilline – Pharma Confiance
online medicijnen kopen pharmacy nl medicijnen zonder recept kopen
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# Medicijn Punt
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# quel type de maladie soigne l’amoxicilline ?
PharmaJetzt: versandapotheke versandkostenfrei – Pharma Jetzt
Pharma Connect USA claritin d pharmacy us online pharmacy clomid
http://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
apotheke lieferung: gГјnstige online apotheke – abotheke
buy nexium online pharmacy Pharma Connect USA Pharma Connect USA
https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/# zoloft online pharmacy no prescription
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
best online pharmacy viagra: cialis european pharmacy – PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Connect USA PharmaConnectUSA Albenza
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# belgische online apotheek
Medicijn Punt de online apotheek medicijnen kopen online
Pharma Confiance: meilleur site de pharmacie en ligne – argel 7 arthrose
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# tadalafil douleur jambe
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# monuril homme
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# medikamente auf rechnung bestellen
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
site pharmacie en ligne: pharmacie enligne – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Jetzt meine online apotheke PharmaJetzt
protection gros orteil: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# sildГ©nafil 25 mg sans ordonnance
pdg test Pharma Confiance shampooing ketoderm
online medicijnen kopen zonder recept: Medicijn Punt – Medicijn Punt
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# tetine avent natural 3
apotek online online recept Medicijn Punt
apteka internetowa nl: internetapotheek – Medicijn Punt
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# Pharma Confiance
PharmaConnectUSA tamiflu which pharmacy has the best deal can you buy viagra from pharmacy
http://pharmajetzt.com/# online apoteken
PharmaJetzt: Pharma Jetzt – apotheke bestellen
http://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
Pharma Connect USA best online cialis pharmacy reviews Pharma Connect USA
apotheke internet versandkostenfrei: shopping apotheke – PharmaJetzt
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
MedicijnPunt: apotheek nl online – apotheke niederlande
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# target pharmacy nexium
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# Pharma Confiance
Medicijn Punt Medicijn Punt MedicijnPunt
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
Pharma Confiance: nhco pharmacie – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Jetzt mediherz versandapotheke online shop shopapothe
https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/# PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Connect USA: PharmaConnectUSA – Pharma Connect USA
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# parapharmacie luneville
Pharma Confiance pharmacie marche urgo pharmacien
https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/# tretinoin cream pharmacy
PharmaConnectUSA: kamagra online pharmacy – Pharma Connect USA
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
http://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
ihre online apotheke: cantura akut 12 apotheke – apotheke online ohne versandkosten
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# Pharma Jetzt
http://pharmajetzt.com/# online apothek
MedicijnPunt medicijnen aanvragen MedicijnPunt
PharmaJetzt: shop apothrke – bestellapotheken
https://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
apotheek recept MedicijnPunt Medicijn Punt
ordonnance pharmacie en ligne: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# vitamine c upsa combien par jour
https://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
Pharma Connect USA: Pharma Connect USA – PharmaConnectUSA
PharmaJetzt medicine online shop internetapotheke
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – pharmacie vГ©tГ©rinaire discount
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# Pharma Confiance
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Connect USA depo provera pharmacy pharmacy direct gabapentin
Medicijn Punt: holandia apteka internetowa – MedicijnPunt
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# fleur de bach n 39 avis
PharmaJetzt: PharmaJetzt – Pharma Jetzt
online recept holandia apteka internetowa Medicijn Punt
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
PharmaConnectUSA: PharmaConnectUSA – Pharma Connect USA
http://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
algotherm lyon: produit furterer avis – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Jetzt Pharma Jetzt sofort lieferung apotheke
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# buy nexium online pharmacy
shop aphotheke: Pharma Jetzt – apotal shop apotheke
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# commander medicament
http://pharmajetzt.com/# sofort apotheke
pharmacy online australia free shipping acyclovir cream online pharmacy northern pharmacy
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – pharmacie*
PharmaJetzt: Pharma Jetzt – internet apotheke test
https://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
abotheke Pharma Jetzt PharmaJetzt
http://pharmajetzt.com/# online apotheke pille
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Connect USA no prior prescription required pharmacy Pharma Connect USA
mijn medicijn bestellen: online drugstore netherlands – medicijnen aanvragen apotheek
http://medicijnpunt.com/# Medicijn Punt
Pharma Connect USA: Pharma Connect USA – wedgewood pharmacy naltrexone
http://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/# PharmaConnectUSA
Medicijn Punt: apotheker medicatie – aptoheek
Pharma Jetzt: Pharma Jetzt – apozheke
Pharma Connect USA Pharma Connect USA Pharma Connect USA
https://tijuanameds.shop/# TijuanaMeds
https://tijuanameds.shop/# п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
pharmacy wholesalers canada: CanRx Direct – canadian discount pharmacy
indian pharmacy india pharmacy pharmacy website india
http://canrxdirect.com/# canada rx pharmacy
legitimate canadian pharmacy online: CanRx Direct – canada pharmacy world
https://tijuanameds.shop/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
https://tijuanameds.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
TijuanaMeds mexico drug stores pharmacies TijuanaMeds
https://tijuanameds.com/# TijuanaMeds
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa buying prescription drugs in mexico online TijuanaMeds
http://indimedsdirect.com/# IndiMeds Direct
https://canrxdirect.shop/# canadian pharmacies comparison
medicine in mexico pharmacies purple pharmacy mexico price list TijuanaMeds
https://canrxdirect.com/# buying from canadian pharmacies
IndiMeds Direct reputable indian pharmacies IndiMeds Direct
https://tijuanameds.com/# mexican mail order pharmacies
https://indimedsdirect.com/# IndiMeds Direct
https://indimedsdirect.shop/# IndiMeds Direct
IndiMeds Direct: IndiMeds Direct – IndiMeds Direct
IndiMeds Direct indianpharmacy com IndiMeds Direct
https://canrxdirect.com/# cheap canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us: CanRx Direct – best canadian pharmacy online
https://farmaciaasequible.shop/# Farmacia Asequible
barcelona farmacia diu mirena precio farmacia espaГ±a Farmacia Asequible
generic viagra mexico pharmacy: RxFree Meds – RxFree Meds
https://farmaciaasequible.com/# farmacias madrid
http://rxfreemeds.com/# accurate rx pharmacy
enclomiphene online: enclomiphene citrate – enclomiphene
enclomiphene online enclomiphene price enclomiphene for men
http://rxfreemeds.com/# RxFree Meds
https://enclomiphenebestprice.shop/# enclomiphene citrate
provigil pharmacy express: percocet cost pharmacy – RxFree Meds
enclomiphene best price enclomiphene citrate enclomiphene for men
http://farmaciaasequible.com/# Farmacia Asequible
enclomiphene online: buy enclomiphene online – enclomiphene online
enclomiphene citrate enclomiphene for men enclomiphene for sale
https://farmaciaasequible.shop/# Farmacia Asequible
RxFree Meds RxFree Meds advair pharmacy coupons
RxFree Meds: RxFree Meds – ativan online pharmacy
http://farmaciaasequible.com/# Farmacia Asequible
codigo promocional farmacia barata tadalafilo 5 mg 28 comprimidos precio farmacia 86
enclomiphene for sale: enclomiphene price – enclomiphene testosterone
https://enclomiphenebestprice.com/# enclomiphene best price
enclomiphene online enclomiphene buy enclomiphene best price
enclomiphene buy: enclomiphene buy – buy enclomiphene online
https://rxfreemeds.shop/# RxFree Meds
https://farmaciaasequible.com/# citrafleet no hace efecto
Farmacia Asequible: Farmacia Asequible – vibrador barato
http://enclomiphenebestprice.com/# buy enclomiphene online
enclomiphene for sale enclomiphene enclomiphene buy
https://enclomiphenebestprice.com/# enclomiphene testosterone
https://enclomiphenebestprice.shop/# buy enclomiphene online
tesco uk pharmacy viagra generic propecia united pharmacy fluoxetine online pharmacy
https://rxfreemeds.com/# RxFree Meds
mobic online pharmacy buy cialis online us pharmacy RxFree Meds
Farmacia Asequible: medicamentos a domicilio 24 horas – mejor champГє para niГ±os ocu
https://rxfreemeds.shop/# motion sickness
https://enclomiphenebestprice.com/# enclomiphene for sale
enclomiphene testosterone enclomiphene citrate enclomiphene online
https://farmaciaasequible.shop/# Farmacia Asequible
xeloda specialty pharmacy: pharmacy artane – RxFree Meds
https://enclomiphenebestprice.shop/# enclomiphene price
pantoprazole online pharmacy RxFree Meds sky pharmacy
https://rxfreemeds.com/# RxFree Meds
https://rxfreemeds.com/# japan pharmacy online
farmacia sol Farmacia Asequible Farmacia Asequible
wholesale pharmacy online: online pharmacy misoprostol – RxFree Meds