Introduction

Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS) is a complex issue that emerges in the context of child custody disputes. It involves one parent (the alienating parent) manipulating a child to reject the other parent (the targeted parent), often leading to long-term emotional and psychological harm to the child. While PAS has gained significant recognition globally, its status in Indian law remains somewhat ambiguous. This article explores the legal recognition of PAS in Indian courts, examines relevant Indian laws, and reviews recent case law developments.

Understanding Parental Alienation Syndrome

Parental Alienation Syndrome, first coined by Dr. Richard Gardner in the 1980s, describes a situation where a child becomes estranged from one parent due to the psychological manipulation by the other parent. The syndrome is characterized by unjustified denigration and rejection of one parent, often without valid reasons. It’s important to note that PAS is distinct from cases where a child’s rejection of a parent is justified, such as in instances of abuse or neglect.

Legal Framework in India

In India, there is no specific law addressing Parental Alienation Syndrome. However, the legal framework governing child custody and the welfare of children provides some avenues to address issues related to PAS. The following laws are relevant in this context:

1. The Guardian and Wards Act, 1890: This Act is one of the primary laws governing the appointment of guardians for minors in India. Section 17 of the Act emphasizes that the welfare of the child is the paramount consideration in deciding guardianship and custody matters. The court, while determining custody, considers the child’s age, sex, religion, character, and the parent’s capacity to provide a safe and healthy environment.

2. Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956: Applicable to Hindus, this Act also prioritizes the welfare of the child in custody disputes. Section 6 of the Act designates the father as the natural guardian of a minor, but courts have increasingly considered the child’s best interests over this statutory presumption.

3. The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: Sections 26 and 27 of the Act deal with child custody and property matters in divorce proceedings. The courts have broad discretion to pass orders regarding the custody, maintenance, and education of minor children, ensuring that the child’s welfare is the primary concern.

4. The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (DV Act): Although primarily designed to protect women from domestic violence, the DV Act also provides for child custody orders. Under Section 21, the court can grant temporary custody of children to the aggrieved person and restrain the respondent from disturbing the custody arrangement.

Judicial Recognition of Parental Alienation Syndrome

Indian courts have not explicitly recognized PAS as a medical or psychological syndrome, but the underlying concept of parental alienation has been acknowledged in several judgments. Courts have increasingly become aware of the detrimental impact of one parent’s influence over the child to alienate the other parent.

1. Vivek Singh v. Romani Singh (2017): In this landmark case, the Supreme Court of India dealt with issues of custody and visitation rights. The Court recognized the importance of a child maintaining a healthy relationship with both parents and noted the adverse impact of parental alienation. The judgment emphasized that the court must be vigilant in ensuring that a parent does not manipulate the child to alienate the other parent. The Court directed that any custody arrangement must facilitate the child’s emotional and psychological well-being, including maintaining a bond with both parents.

2. Aparna Bhat v. Mukesh Bhat (2020): The Delhi High Court, while deciding a custody battle, discussed the concept of parental alienation and its adverse effects on children. The court noted that when one parent attempts to influence the child against the other parent, it is crucial to take corrective measures to protect the child’s mental health. The court ordered joint custody in this case, ensuring that both parents had a role in the child’s upbringing.

3. Nivedita Sharma v. Rajeev Sharma (2022): The Punjab and Haryana High Court, in this case, highlighted the importance of preventing parental alienation in custody disputes. The court observed that denying access to one parent could have long-lasting psychological effects on the child. The court ruled that both parents should have access to the child, and any attempts to alienate the child from one parent would not be in the child’s best interest.

Challenges in Addressing Parental Alienation

Despite judicial acknowledgment, several challenges persist in addressing PAS in India:

1. Lack of Specific Legislation: Unlike some countries that have specific laws addressing PAS, India lacks a dedicated legal framework. This absence makes it difficult for courts to identify and address PAS systematically.

2. Judicial Discretion: The broad discretion granted to courts in custody matters can lead to inconsistent judgments. While some courts have recognized and acted against parental alienation, others may not give it due importance, leading to varied outcomes.

3. Lack of Awareness: There is a general lack of awareness about PAS among legal practitioners, judges, and even parents. This lack of understanding can result in the failure to identify and address cases of parental alienation effectively.

4. Enforcement Issues: Even when courts recognize PAS and issue orders to protect the child’s welfare, enforcement remains a challenge. Ensuring compliance with custody and visitation orders is often difficult, especially when one parent is determined to alienate the child.

Conclusion

Parental Alienation Syndrome poses a significant challenge in child custody disputes, with the potential to cause long-lasting harm to children. While Indian courts have started to acknowledge the detrimental effects of parental alienation, there is a pressing need for specific legislation or guidelines to address this issue more effectively. The welfare of the child must remain the paramount consideration in all custody matters, and steps should be taken to prevent and mitigate the effects of parental alienation.

Moving forward, it is crucial for legal practitioners and courts to be more aware of PAS and its implications. Greater awareness and consistent judicial approaches can help ensure that the best interests of the child are always protected, allowing children to maintain healthy relationships with both parents, free from undue influence and manipulation.

Advocate Charu Shishodia (Legal Associate)

81 Replies to “Parental Alienation Syndrome in Indian Courts: Legal Recognition & Recent Cases”

  1. by PatrickSpone 5 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm

  2. by PatrickSpone 4 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# rybelsus and alcohol

  3. by BillySiz 4 days ago

    SemagluPharm: SemagluPharm – SemagluPharm

  4. by AlbertoNeire 4 days ago

    CrestorPharm Crestor Pharm CrestorPharm

  5. by Alfonsoonera 4 days ago

    prednisone pills cost: can you buy prednisone over the counter – prednisone buying

  6. by PatrickSpone 4 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  7. by BillySiz 4 days ago

    order prednisone: prednisone brand name – PredniPharm

  8. by AlbertoNeire 4 days ago

    atorvastatin 10mg price should you take lipitor in the morning or at night LipiPharm

  9. by Alfonsoonera 4 days ago

    п»їBuy Crestor without prescription: crestor cause weight gain – CrestorPharm

  10. by PatrickSpone 4 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  11. by BillySiz 4 days ago

    Rosuvastatin tablets without doctor approval: No doctor visit required statins – CrestorPharm

  12. by AlbertoNeire 4 days ago

    LipiPharm Lipi Pharm Lipi Pharm

  13. by Alfonsoonera 4 days ago

    does lipitor cause high blood pressure: Lipi Pharm – LipiPharm

  14. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  15. by BillySiz 3 days ago

    atorvastatin and weight gain: Lipi Pharm – Order cholesterol medication online

  16. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    crestor kidney damage: why take crestor at night – omega 3 acid vs crestor

  17. by AlbertoNeire 3 days ago

    Semaglu Pharm rybelsus weight loss pills Affordable Rybelsus price

  18. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# rybelsus to mounjaro conversion

  19. by JamesMok 3 days ago

    https://prednipharm.shop/# prednisone daily

  20. by BillySiz 3 days ago

    LipiPharm: is there a lawsuit against lipitor – apo atorvastatin

  21. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    prednisone 12 mg: Predni Pharm – Predni Pharm

  22. by AlbertoNeire 3 days ago

    Best price for Crestor online USA CrestorPharm what should i avoid when taking rosuvastatin?

  23. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# Safe delivery in the US

  24. by BillySiz 3 days ago

    Semaglu Pharm: Semaglu Pharm – semaglutide glp 1

  25. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  26. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    CrestorPharm: crestor for sale – CrestorPharm

  27. by AlbertoNeire 3 days ago

    Affordable Lipitor alternatives USA Lipi Pharm Atorvastatin online pharmacy

  28. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm

  29. by BillySiz 3 days ago

    semaglutide shots near me: Semaglu Pharm – how to give yourself a shot of semaglutide

  30. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    atorvastatin 80: LipiPharm – atorvastatin and grapefruit

  31. by AlbertoNeire 3 days ago

    LipiPharm Lipi Pharm Order cholesterol medication online

  32. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  33. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    Predni Pharm: prednisone tablets india – Predni Pharm

  34. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    PredniPharm: prednisone 4mg – can you buy prednisone over the counter in usa

  35. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    PredniPharm prednisone 20mg capsule Predni Pharm

  36. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.shop/# does insurance cover semaglutide

  37. by JamesMok 2 days ago

    https://prednipharm.shop/# prednisone canada prices

  38. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    CrestorPharm: crestor side effects alcohol – rosuvastatin package insert

  39. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    rybelsus administration: semaglutide weight loss dosage chart ml – No prescription diabetes meds online

  40. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    Crestor Pharm Order rosuvastatin online legally CrestorPharm

  41. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.shop/# Semaglu Pharm

  42. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    Over-the-counter Crestor USA: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm

  43. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    what is crestor used for: Buy statins online discreet shipping – Crestor Pharm

  44. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    No prescription diabetes meds online Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm

  45. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  46. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    prednisone 2.5 mg price: Predni Pharm – prednisone price south africa

  47. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    No prescription diabetes meds online: SemagluPharm – Semaglu Pharm

  48. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    rybelsus cardiovascular benefits semaglutide tablets rybelsus semaglutide

  49. by PatrickSpone 1 day ago

    https://semaglupharm.shop/# Online pharmacy Rybelsus

  50. by Alfonsoonera 1 day ago

    Crestor Pharm: Crestor Pharm – does crestor cause bruising

  51. by BillySiz 1 day ago

    semaglutide expiration: Semaglu Pharm – SemagluPharm

  52. by AlbertoNeire 1 day ago

    Lipi Pharm LipiPharm Lipi Pharm

  53. by PatrickSpone 1 day ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# Rybelsus for blood sugar control

  54. by JamesRor 1 day ago

    https://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global

  55. by MichelLiard 1 day ago

    canadian pharmacy scam: canadian pharmacy sarasota – canadian pharmacy

  56. by Roberttooff 1 day ago

    indian pharmacy: reputable indian pharmacies – India Pharm Global

  57. by Samuelepize 1 day ago

    safe canadian pharmacies canadian valley pharmacy my canadian pharmacy

  58. by Roberthom 1 day ago

    http://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico

  59. by MichelLiard 21 hours ago

    buying prescription drugs in mexico online: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – Meds From Mexico

  60. by Roberttooff 20 hours ago

    canadian drugstore online: www canadianonlinepharmacy – canada cloud pharmacy

  61. by Samuelepize 20 hours ago

    canadian pharmacy 24 Canada Pharm Global adderall canadian pharmacy

  62. by MichelLiard 17 hours ago

    India Pharm Global: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global

  63. by Samuelepize 15 hours ago

    cheapest online pharmacy india indian pharmacies safe top 10 online pharmacy in india

  64. by Roberttooff 15 hours ago

    Meds From Mexico: buying prescription drugs in mexico – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  65. by MichelLiard 12 hours ago

    canada pharmacy reviews: Canada Pharm Global – canadian pharmacy

  66. by Roberthom 11 hours ago

    http://canadapharmglobal.com/# best rated canadian pharmacy

  67. by Samuelepize 10 hours ago

    purple pharmacy mexico price list medicine in mexico pharmacies Meds From Mexico

  68. by Roberttooff 10 hours ago

    top online pharmacy india: India Pharm Global – reputable indian online pharmacy

  69. by JamesRor 9 hours ago

    http://canadapharmglobal.com/# canadian pharmacy ratings

  70. by MichelLiard 8 hours ago

    mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: Meds From Mexico – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  71. by Roberthom 7 hours ago

    https://indiapharmglobal.shop/# india pharmacy mail order

  72. by Samuelepize 5 hours ago

    India Pharm Global best online pharmacy india India Pharm Global

  73. by Roberttooff 5 hours ago

    reputable mexican pharmacies online: Meds From Mexico – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  74. by MichelLiard 3 hours ago

    India Pharm Global: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global

  75. by Roberthom 3 hours ago

    https://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.