Harvinder Singh @ Bachhu V. The State of Himachal Pradesh,

Criminal APPEAL No. 266-267 OF 2015

While overturning the Himachal Pradesh High Court’s ruling, which said that Prosecution Witness (PW) 1’s testimony had to be accepted because he was an educated and devout individual, the Bench of Justices MM Sundresh and JB Pardiwala made these observations. The Supreme Court clarified that a witness’s reputation can be ascertained by considering their “conduct as a witness,” as specified in Section 8 of the Evidence Act, by stating: According to Section 8 of the Evidence Act, a witness’s behaviour is a relevant factor in determining, establishing, and proving their reputation. It further stated that their reputation was not as important when a witness’s behaviour deviated from typical human behaviour.

It stated that the prosecution had not proven the accusations beyond a reasonable doubt and that the trial court had provided strong justification for its decision to grant an acquittal.

The bench also commented on the case’s use of circumstantial evidence, double presumption, and the absence of meaningful witness cross-examination. 

Issue:

In a decision released on October 13, 2023, the Supreme Court addressed the question of whether a person’s high school degree and their reputation as a God-fearing person may be enough to help them gain favour. The Himachal Pradesh High Court used PW1, a knowledgeable and devout witness, as testimonial evidence in a case challenging a murder and attempted rape conviction.

Facts of the Case:

The appellant’s acquittal by the lower court was overturned by the High Court, which found him guilty of attempted rape and murder. The testimony of PW1, who was thought to be an intelligent and devout man, served as a major foundation for the High Court’s decision. The High Court found that PW1’s background made his testimony credible.

Arguments Presented by Parties:

  • According to the prosecution, PW1’s well-educated and devout background should provide weight to his testimony and support the appellant’s conviction.
  • The defence contended that PW1’s reputation and character were overly relied upon by the High Court. They argued that under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, the court ought to consider both the witness’s demeanour and all of the evidence presented.

The reasoning for the Judgment:

Character and reputation are closely related, according to a ruling by Justices M. M. Sundresh and J. B. Pardiwala of the Supreme Court. However, they pointed out that if a witness’s behaviour raises questions, a court shouldn’t rely solely on their past, especially in an appeal hearing. Under Section 8 of the Evidence Act, a witness’s actions are crucial in determining their reputation.

Judgment:

The trial court’s verdict of acquittal was upheld by the Supreme Court, which reversed the High Court’s ruling. The prosecution had not shown its case beyond a reasonable question, the court said, so the appellant was entitled to the benefit of the doubt. The lower court’s acquittal was reinstated after it was decided that the finding of the High Court was unreasonable. 

Adv. Khanak Sharma (D\1710\2023)

72 Replies to “One cannot claim that someone has a good reputation just because they are well-educated and devout.”

  1. by RobertHip 3 months ago

    Leading the charge in international pharmacy standards.
    can you buy cheap lisinopril price
    They always offer alternatives and suggestions.

  2. by LorenzoREP 3 months ago

    The pharmacists are always updated with the latest in medicine.
    how to get cheap clomid online
    A trailblazer in international pharmacy practices.

  3. by BryanPleks 3 months ago

    Their global medical liaisons ensure top-quality care.
    can i buy cheap cipro prices
    Always responsive, regardless of time zones.

  4. by BryanPleks 3 months ago

    Always greeted with warmth and professionalism.
    drug interaction lyrica and gabapentin
    I always feel valued and heard at this pharmacy.

  5. by BryanPleks 3 months ago

    The staff provides excellent advice on over-the-counter choices.
    where can i get cytotec pills in south africa
    Consistently excellent, year after year.

  6. by PatrickSpone 5 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.shop/# symptoms of semaglutide

  7. by BillySiz 4 days ago

    Where to buy Semaglutide legally: Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews – Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews

  8. by AlbertoNeire 4 days ago

    Buy cholesterol medicine online cheap Crestor Pharm rosuvastatin muscle twitching

  9. by Alfonsoonera 4 days ago

    Crestor Pharm: CrestorPharm – crestor doses available

  10. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglutide tablets without prescription

  11. by BillySiz 3 days ago

    what are the doses of semaglutide: SemagluPharm – Affordable Rybelsus price

  12. by AlbertoNeire 3 days ago

    prednisone 10 mg canada prednisone oral PredniPharm

  13. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    Crestor Pharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm

  14. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm

  15. by BillySiz 3 days ago

    Predni Pharm: Predni Pharm – PredniPharm

  16. by AlbertoNeire 3 days ago

    Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm Online pharmacy Rybelsus

  17. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    Predni Pharm: PredniPharm – Predni Pharm

  18. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# rybelsus alternatives

  19. by AlbertoNeire 3 days ago

    Crestor Pharm Buy statins online discreet shipping does crestor cause erectile dysfunction

  20. by BillySiz 3 days ago

    Predni Pharm: buy 40 mg prednisone – generic prednisone otc

  21. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    Affordable Rybelsus price: semaglutide vs zepbound – Semaglu Pharm

  22. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# No prescription diabetes meds online

  23. by Alfonsoonera 3 days ago

    can atorvastatin cause dizziness: No RX Lipitor online – Lipi Pharm

  24. by PatrickSpone 3 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.shop/# how much weight can you lose with semaglutide

  25. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    PredniPharm buy prednisone online usa cheap prednisone 20 mg

  26. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    Order rosuvastatin online legally: what happens if you stop taking rosuvastatin – does rosuvastatin raise blood pressure

  27. by JamesMok 2 days ago

    https://lipipharm.shop/# No RX Lipitor online

  28. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    Predni Pharm: PredniPharm – Predni Pharm

  29. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  30. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm

  31. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    LipiPharm LipiPharm FDA-approved generic statins online

  32. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    order prednisone on line: PredniPharm – prednisone 20 mg in india

  33. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    SemagluPharm: Semaglu Pharm – Semaglu Pharm

  34. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# over the counter semaglutide

  35. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm Order Rybelsus discreetly

  36. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    Semaglu Pharm: does rybelsus cause insomnia – Semaglu Pharm

  37. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    atorvastatin intensity: LipiPharm – when to take atorvastatin dosage

  38. by PatrickSpone 2 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm

  39. by AlbertoNeire 2 days ago

    LipiPharm Lipi Pharm Generic Lipitor fast delivery

  40. by Alfonsoonera 2 days ago

    ezetimibe and crestor: CrestorPharm – Rosuvastatin tablets without doctor approval

  41. by BillySiz 2 days ago

    Lipi Pharm: LipiPharm – Safe atorvastatin purchase without RX

  42. by PatrickSpone 1 day ago

    http://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm

  43. by AlbertoNeire 1 day ago

    SemagluPharm Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews SemagluPharm

  44. by Alfonsoonera 1 day ago

    Generic Lipitor fast delivery: lipitor and – Lipi Pharm

  45. by BillySiz 1 day ago

    Where to buy Semaglutide legally: Semaglu Pharm – No prescription diabetes meds online

  46. by PatrickSpone 1 day ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# is metformin a semaglutide

  47. by Alfonsoonera 1 day ago

    Rybelsus for blood sugar control: how long has semaglutide been on the market – SemagluPharm

  48. by BillySiz 1 day ago

    Safe atorvastatin purchase without RX: FDA-approved generic statins online – Lipi Pharm

  49. by AlbertoNeire 20 hours ago

    FDA-approved generic statins online LipiPharm what is atorvastatin 80 mg used for

  50. by Alfonsoonera 19 hours ago

    LipiPharm: what should be avoided when taking lipitor? – Lipi Pharm

  51. by BillySiz 19 hours ago

    no prescription prednisone canadian pharmacy: prednisone in india – purchase prednisone

  52. by Samuelepize 14 hours ago

    top 10 pharmacies in india India Pharm Global best online pharmacy india

  53. by MichelLiard 14 hours ago

    canadian pharmacy no rx needed: Canada Pharm Global – safe canadian pharmacy

  54. by Roberttooff 13 hours ago

    best online pharmacies in mexico: Meds From Mexico – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  55. by MichelLiard 9 hours ago

    Online medicine home delivery: mail order pharmacy india – India Pharm Global

  56. by Samuelepize 9 hours ago

    Meds From Mexico Meds From Mexico п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  57. by Roberthom 8 hours ago

    https://canadapharmglobal.com/# ordering drugs from canada

  58. by Roberttooff 8 hours ago

    Meds From Mexico: pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa – buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  59. by JamesRor 7 hours ago

    https://medsfrommexico.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online

  60. by MichelLiard 5 hours ago

    canadian discount pharmacy: Canada Pharm Global – canadian pharmacy world

  61. by Samuelepize 4 hours ago

    Meds From Mexico mexican pharmaceuticals online Meds From Mexico

  62. by Roberthom 4 hours ago

    https://canadapharmglobal.com/# canada drug pharmacy

  63. by Roberttooff 3 hours ago

    Meds From Mexico: mexican mail order pharmacies – Meds From Mexico

  64. by MichelLiard 30 minutes ago

    Meds From Mexico: Meds From Mexico – Meds From Mexico

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.