The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) is a significant legislative development aimed at modernizing criminal procedure in India. However, within its framework, certain provisions have raised concerns. One such provision is Section 187(2), which has been highlighted for its potential to undermine the rights of accused individuals. This article delves into the paradoxical implications of this section, particularly in the context of hit-and-run cases, and evaluates its impact on justice and liberty.
Understanding Section 187(2) of BNSS
Section 187 of BNSS deals with the procedure when an investigation cannot be completed within twenty-four hours of an arrest. The section is divided into two subsections:
- Section 187(1): Mandates that if an investigation cannot be completed within twenty-four hours, the officer in charge must forward the accused to the nearest Magistrate, along with a copy of the diary entries related to the case.
- Section 187(2): Provides the Magistrate with the authority to authorize the detention of the accused in “such custody as the Magistrate thinks fit” for a term not exceeding fifteen days in total, within the initial forty or sixty days, depending on the case. This custody can be either police or judicial, and can be divided into parts within the allowed period.
The Paradox and Its Implications
The primary issue with Section 187(2) lies in its potential for misapplication due to its ambiguous language. The provision does not explicitly limit the maximum duration of police custody, unlike the corresponding clause in the Cr.P.C. (Code of Criminal Procedure), which restricts police custody to fifteen days. Instead, Section 187(2) permits a Magistrate to alternately authorize police custody and judicial custody, potentially leading to extended periods of police detention.
For instance, a Magistrate could authorize fifteen days of police custody, followed by a day’s judicial custody, and then another fifteen days of police custody, and so on, within the first forty or sixty days. This could result in prolonged periods of police custody, well beyond what was presumably intended by the drafters of the BNSS.
Legislative Intent vs. Legislative Reality
The apparent gap between legislative intent and the actual wording of Section 187(2) reflects a significant concern. The Home Minister’s speech in the Lok Sabha suggested that the total duration of police custody should be capped at fifteen days within the initial forty or sixty days. However, this verbal clarification does not amend the statutory language and thus fails to address the underlying issue in the legal text.
The absence of a clear restriction on police custody duration in the statute itself allows for potential misuse. This discrepancy highlights a broader issue with legislative drafting where the precision of legal language is crucial to ensure that the statute operates as intended.
Judicial Interpretation and the Need for Reform
Justice M.N. Venkatachaliah’s observation in Dinesh Chandra Jamnadas Gandhi v. State of Gujarat underscores the necessity for precise legislative drafting. According to Justice Venkatachaliah, the degree of precision in legal text should prevent both misinterpretation and manipulation.
In the case of Section 187(2), the lack of specificity opens avenues for legal loopholes and misapplication. The section, as currently worded, can lead to extended periods of police custody that may infringe on the liberty of accused persons. This is particularly concerning in hit-and-run cases, where the accused could be subjected to prolonged detention, affecting their fundamental rights.
Proposed Amendments and Future Directions
To address the issues with Section 187(2), a few amendments could be considered:
- Explicit Limitation on Police Custody: Incorporating a clear restriction on the maximum duration of police custody, similar to the Cr.P.C., would align the provision with legislative intent and prevent misuse.
- Clarification of Custody Terms: Revising the language to explicitly define the terms and limits of custody could enhance clarity and reduce the risk of legal loopholes.
- Judicial Oversight: Ensuring that extended periods of custody require a higher level of judicial scrutiny could safeguard against potential abuses.
The BNSS represents a progressive step in the evolution of criminal law in India. However, for it to effectively serve justice and protect individual rights, careful attention must be given to its provisions. Section 187(2) of BNSS, with its current ambiguities, illustrates the critical need for precision in legal drafting to balance the imperatives of justice and individual liberty.
~Laksh Verma(Trainee)
787709 263286Hi there, just became aware of your weblog by means of Google, and located that it is actually informative. Im gonna watch out for brussels. I will appreciate should you continue this in future. Lots of folks will likely be benefited from your writing. Cheers! 831015
197847 77967If you are needing to produce alteration in an individuals llife, during i would say the Are typically Bodyweight peeling off pounds training course are a wide path in the direction of gaining any search. la weight loss 877961
539667 276271I like the valuable details you offer within your articles. Ill bookmark your weblog and check again here often. Im quite certain I will learn a lot of new stuff correct here! Excellent luck for the next! 242364
795290 959154Hey there. I want to to inquire somethingis this a wordpress weblog as we are thinking about shifting more than to WP. Also did you make this theme on your personal? Thanks. 288299
954567 923099I was just searching for this information for a while. After six hours of continuous Googleing, at last I got it in your web site. 966605
95861 456582Companion, this internet site is going to be fabolous, i merely like it 374159
350118 21903Hey, are you having issues with your hosting? I needed to refresh the page about million times to get the page to load. Just saying 832027
764315 229368The Spirit of the Lord is with them that fear him. 128158
967731 976995magnificent submit, really informative. I ponder why the opposite experts of this sector dont realize this. You should proceed your writing. Im positive, youve a fantastic readers base already! 857038
110225 117793It is really a good and useful piece of information. Im glad that you just shared this valuable info with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for sharing. 403479
645770 498642you use a wonderful weblog here! do you require to make some invite posts on my blog? 434192
77070 745681Cheapest player speeches and toasts, or possibly toasts. continue to be brought about real estate . during evening reception tend to be likely to just be comic, witty and therefore instructive as well. very best man speeches totally free 779746
406664 571798There is noticeably big dollars to understand about this. I suppose you made particular nice points in capabilities also. 418123
723965 646598Hello Guru, what entice you to post an article. This post was very interesting, specifically since I was looking for thoughts on this topic last Thursday. 479307
637072 610317Dead written topic matter, Genuinely enjoyed reading by means of . 108821
691130 181826This design is steller! You obviously know how to keep a reader amused. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent job. I really enjoyed what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it. Too cool! 189713
24367 449515Hi. Cool post. Theres an concern together with your website in chrome, and you could want to test this The browser may be the marketplace chief and a excellent element of folks will omit your superb writing because of this issue. 911119
384766 722234Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in reality was a amusement account it. Look complicated to far delivered agreeable from you! Nevertheless, how can we keep in touch? 491202
598184 609002When I saw this page was like wow. Thanks for putting your effort in publishing this post. 161889