In the realm of criminal justice, the concept of mercy holds a significant place, often manifesting through the mechanism of mercy petitions. In India, the process of filing a mercy petition serves as a crucial avenue for individuals convicted of serious offences to appeal for clemency from the highest executive authority of the nation, the President or the Governor, depending on the jurisdiction. This article aims to delve into the legal framework surrounding mercy petitions in India, elucidating its purpose, procedure, and significance within the realm of criminal law.
Purpose of Mercy Petitions
Mercy petitions constitute a fundamental aspect of the criminal justice system aimed at addressing situations where the strict application of law might lead to undue harshness or injustice. The invocation of mercy seeks to temper justice with compassion, considering factors such as mitigating circumstances, the possibility of reformation, and humanitarian grounds. It provides a safety valve in cases where the judicial process, despite its meticulousness, fails to account for individual nuances or instances where the imposition of the death penalty or other severe punishments may be deemed excessive.
Legal Basis for Mercy Petitions
The authority to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, or remissions of punishment stems from the powers vested in the President under Article 72 of the Indian Constitution and in Governors under Article 161. These provisions bestow upon the executive the discretion to exercise mercy in appropriate cases. While Article 72 pertains to mercy petitions in cases tried by a court-martial or in matters relating to offences against laws enacted by Parliament, Article 161 extends similar powers to the Governors of states.
Procedure for Filing Mercy Petitions
The procedure for filing a mercy petition varies depending on whether the case falls under the purview of the President or the Governor. Typically, the convicted individual or their legal representative submits a mercy petition addressed to the President or Governor, respectively, detailing grounds for mercy and any mitigating factors. The mercy petition is then scrutinized by the Home Ministry or concerned authorities, who prepare a recommendation for the President’s or Governor’s consideration. This recommendation may include legal opinions, facts of the case, and any other relevant information.
Upon receipt of the recommendation, the President or Governor exercises their discretion in deciding whether to grant mercy. This decision is arrived at after due consideration of various factors, including the gravity of the offence, the character of the offender, public interest, and humanitarian grounds. While the executive is not bound by the decision of lower courts or the recommendation of the Home Ministry, it typically gives weight to such opinions in reaching a decision.
Judicial Review of Mercy Petitions
While the power to grant mercy lies with the executive, the judiciary plays a crucial role in ensuring that the process adheres to principles of fairness and justice. The scope of judicial review concerning mercy petitions primarily revolves around examining the procedural aspects of the decision-making process rather than delving into the merits of the case itself. The judiciary ensures that the executive’s decision is not arbitrary, mala fide, or based on irrelevant considerations.
In the landmark case of Kehar Singh v. Union of India, the Supreme Court held that while the President’s power under Article 72 is absolute, it is not beyond judicial review. The court emphasized that the President’s decision must be based on valid considerations and not on extraneous or irrelevant factors. Similarly, in Epuru Sudhakar & Anr. v. Govt. of A.P. & Ors., the Supreme Court reiterated that the exercise of mercy powers by the President or Governor is subject to judicial review to prevent any manifest injustice.
Significance and Criticisms
Mercy petitions play a significant role in fostering a humane and just criminal justice system. They provide an avenue for redressal in cases where the imposition of strict legal penalties may lead to disproportionate outcomes. Moreover, mercy petitions allow for individual circumstances to be considered, promoting the principles of fairness and compassion in the administration of justice.
However, the process of mercy petitions has faced criticism on various fronts. Critics argue that it introduces an element of arbitrariness and subjectivity in the justice system, as the decision ultimately rests on the discretion of the executive. Moreover, delays in deciding mercy petitions have been a cause for concern, leading to prolonged agony for the convict and their families. Additionally, there have been instances where mercy petitions have been influenced by political considerations rather than legal or humanitarian grounds, undermining the integrity of the process.
Conclusion
Mercy petitions constitute a vital aspect of the Indian legal framework, offering a mechanism for individuals convicted of serious offences to appeal for clemency. Rooted in principles of compassion and fairness, mercy petitions allow for individual circumstances to be considered in the administration of justice. While the power to grant mercy rests with the executive, judicial oversight ensures that the process adheres to principles of fairness and justice. Moving forward, it is imperative to strike a balance between the need for compassion and the imperative of upholding the rule of law in the exercise of mercy powers
Adv. Khanak Sharma
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Semaglu Pharm
ordering prednisone: how much is prednisone 10 mg – average price of prednisone
rybelsus para que sirve [url=https://semaglupharm.com/#]SemagluPharm[/url] SemagluPharm
Atorvastatin online pharmacy: Lipi Pharm – Lipi Pharm
http://lipipharm.com/# Cheap Lipitor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg
semaglutide denver [url=https://semaglupharm.com/#]semaglutide 2.5mg dosing[/url] Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews
should i take atorvastatin in the morning or at night: Lipi Pharm – LipiPharm
FDA-approved generic statins online [url=https://lipipharm.shop/#]No RX Lipitor online[/url] Cheap Lipitor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg
Predni Pharm: fast shipping prednisone – PredniPharm
http://prednipharm.com/# prednisone without rx
Semaglu Pharm [url=http://semaglupharm.com/#]Semaglu Pharm[/url] Semaglu Pharm
PredniPharm [url=https://prednipharm.com/#]prednisone 10 mg tablets[/url] PredniPharm
Buy cholesterol medicine online cheap: can you take magnesium glycinate with rosuvastatin – Crestor Pharm
https://semaglupharm.com/# still hungry on semaglutide
USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery [url=http://lipipharm.com/#]is crestor better than lipitor[/url] Lipi Pharm
lipitor common side effects: п»їBuy Lipitor without prescription USA – Lipi Pharm
prednisone in india [url=https://prednipharm.shop/#]40 mg daily prednisone[/url] PredniPharm
PredniPharm: Predni Pharm – prednisone 20mg nz
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Rybelsus 3mg 7mg 14mg
can you drink with lipitor [url=https://lipipharm.shop/#]п»їBuy Lipitor without prescription USA[/url] Lipi Pharm
why do you take crestor at night: Best price for Crestor online USA – rosuvastatin nightmares
Affordable Lipitor alternatives USA [url=http://lipipharm.com/#]п»їBuy Lipitor without prescription USA[/url] Lipi Pharm
Crestor Pharm: difference between rosuvastatin and atorvastatin – Generic Crestor for high cholesterol
п»їBuy Lipitor without prescription USA [url=https://lipipharm.shop/#]Lipi Pharm[/url] stopping lipitor
https://crestorpharm.com/# Crestor Pharm
prednisone purchase online: Predni Pharm – prednisone 3 tablets daily
Semaglu Pharm [url=http://semaglupharm.com/#]Semaglu Pharm[/url] semaglutide and constipation
what tier drug is lipitor: Lipi Pharm – LipiPharm
prednisone 2.5 mg daily [url=https://prednipharm.shop/#]prednisone 20 mg generic[/url] prednisone 40 mg tablet
https://canadapharmglobal.com/# canada rx pharmacy
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy: canada pharmacy 24h – canadian pharmacy near me
Meds From Mexico [url=https://medsfrommexico.com/#]mexico drug stores pharmacies[/url] Meds From Mexico
India Pharm Global: indian pharmacy – online shopping pharmacy india
https://indiapharmglobal.shop/# India Pharm Global
ed drugs online from canada [url=https://canadapharmglobal.shop/#]Canada Pharm Global[/url] legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies: buying from online mexican pharmacy – Meds From Mexico
indianpharmacy com [url=http://indiapharmglobal.com/#]India Pharm Global[/url] India Pharm Global
Meds From Mexico: Meds From Mexico – buying from online mexican pharmacy
http://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa [url=https://medsfrommexico.com/#]mexican mail order pharmacies[/url] Meds From Mexico
canadian discount pharmacy: canada cloud pharmacy – canada pharmacy online
buying prescription drugs in mexico online [url=https://medsfrommexico.com/#]mexican mail order pharmacies[/url] Meds From Mexico
mexican mail order pharmacies: Meds From Mexico – Meds From Mexico
https://indiapharmglobal.com/# reputable indian pharmacies
medicine in mexico pharmacies [url=https://medsfrommexico.com/#]mexican drugstore online[/url] Meds From Mexico
my canadian pharmacy: canadian pharmacy 24 com – canadian online drugs
adderall canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadapharmglobal.shop/#]Canada Pharm Global[/url] safe canadian pharmacy
https://canadapharmglobal.com/# canadadrugpharmacy com
drugs from canada: legitimate canadian pharmacies – www canadianonlinepharmacy
canadian medications: Canada Pharm Global – canadian compounding pharmacy
purple pharmacy mexico price list: Meds From Mexico – Meds From Mexico
Papa Farma [url=https://papafarma.com/#]mejor crema de pies ocu[/url] farmaceutico trabajo
https://svenskapharma.shop/# Svenska Pharma
magnesio supremo farmaГЁ: EFarmaciaIt – vitamina dibase prezzo
cejas cerca de mi [url=http://papafarma.com/#]la barata farmacia[/url] Papa Farma
EFarmaciaIt: EFarmaciaIt – siler 50 prezzo
Papa Farma [url=https://papafarma.shop/#]framacias[/url] Papa Farma
https://svenskapharma.com/# apotek öppettider söndag
recept billigt [url=https://svenskapharma.com/#]apotek ombud[/url] när ska man sluta med välling
Rask Apotek: apotek hГҐndkrem – krem mot pigmentflekker apotek
https://efarmaciait.com/# migliori pannolini neonato forum
Svenska Pharma [url=https://svenskapharma.com/#]billiga nappflaskor[/url] Svenska Pharma
ren pГҐ engelska djur: Svenska Pharma – hГ¤mta recept apotek
blodtrycksmätare apotek [url=https://svenskapharma.com/#]proteinbars billigt[/url] Svenska Pharma
Svenska Pharma: Svenska Pharma – Svenska Pharma
https://raskapotek.shop/# morgenkГҐpe apotek
svamp i underlivet apotek [url=https://svenskapharma.com/#]Svenska Pharma[/url] sluta med välling
boqueras embarazo: tienda cbd lugo – farmacia barat
Rask Apotek [url=https://raskapotek.shop/#]Rask Apotek[/url] Rask Apotek
antigentest apotek: Svenska Pharma – apotek tandkrГ¤m
https://raskapotek.shop/# papirtape apotek
Papa Farma [url=http://papafarma.com/#]viagra buy[/url] Papa Farma
akne medicin receptfritt: Svenska Pharma – billigt godis online fri frakt
Rask Apotek [url=https://raskapotek.shop/#]Rask Apotek[/url] vaksine lungebetennelse apotek
test kjГёnnssykdommer apotek: homeopati apotek – tea tree olje apotek
https://papafarma.shop/# farmacia online cordoba
gocce day e night in farmacia [url=http://efarmaciait.com/#]EFarmaciaIt[/url] farmaco lucen
Papa Farma [url=https://papafarma.com/#]farmГЎcia perto de mim[/url] Papa Farma
Svenska Pharma: tablett – Svenska Pharma
https://medicijnpunt.com/# dutch apotheek
best rogue online pharmacy [url=https://pharmaconnectusa.com/#]online pharmacy price checker[/url] mexican pharmacy
pharmacie de garde strasbourg centre: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
nizoral boots pharmacy [url=https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/#]pharmacy[/url] PharmaConnectUSA
versandapotheken online: shop apotheke berlin – PharmaJetzt
http://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
PharmaJetzt [url=https://pharmajetzt.shop/#]apotheke online gГјnstig[/url] pharmacie online
PharmaConnectUSA: accutane online pharmacy – PharmaConnectUSA
Starlix [url=http://pharmaconnectusa.com/#]rite aid 24 hour pharmacy store locator[/url] accutane 40 mg online pharmacy
https://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
betrouwbare online apotheek: Medicijn Punt – MedicijnPunt
apotheken online [url=https://pharmajetzt.shop/#]medikamente sofort liefern[/url] Pharma Jetzt
Pharma Confiance: parapharmacienne – combien de pschitt dans 100 ml
Pharma Confiance [url=https://pharmaconfiance.com/#]Pharma Confiance[/url] Pharma Confiance
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# PharmaConnectUSA
PharmaConnectUSA: PharmaConnectUSA – Pharma Connect USA
PharmaJetzt [url=https://pharmajetzt.shop/#]PharmaJetzt[/url] medikamente bestellen online
Pharma Jetzt: tabletten kaufen – apotehke
Medicijn Punt [url=http://medicijnpunt.com/#]internet apotheek[/url] online doktersrecept
http://medicijnpunt.com/# mijn medicijnkosten
online pharmacy nl: Medicijn Punt – medicine online
luitpold apotheke [url=https://pharmajetzt.shop/#]Pharma Jetzt[/url] shop apotheke versandapotheke
pharma shop avis: pharmacie des drakkars livraison – allergie Г l’eau calcaire
Medicijn Punt [url=http://medicijnpunt.com/#]apteka den haag[/url] Medicijn Punt
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# pharmacie sur le net
Medicijn Punt: Medicijn Punt – online medicijnen kopen
Pharma Confiance [url=https://pharmaconfiance.com/#]tadalafil 5 mg efficacitГ©[/url] chat gbd
MedicijnPunt: Medicijn Punt – mijn medicijnen bestellen
PharmaConnectUSA [url=https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/#]Pharma Connect USA[/url] PharmaConnectUSA
wholesale pharmacy: Pharma Connect USA – online pharmacy dubai
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# amoxicilline et dГ©but de grossesse
apotheken [url=https://medicijnpunt.shop/#]medicijnen bestellen online[/url] MedicijnPunt
online doktersrecept: medicatie online – online drugstore netherlands
https://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
online apotheek nederland met recept [url=https://medicijnpunt.shop/#]MedicijnPunt[/url] Medicijn Punt
PharmaConnectUSA: PharmaConnectUSA – target pharmacy lipitor price
online apotehke [url=https://pharmajetzt.shop/#]arznei gГјnstig[/url] PharmaJetzt
medicamente: apotheken versand – apotheke ohne versandkosten
Medicijn Punt [url=https://medicijnpunt.com/#]MedicijnPunt[/url] Medicijn Punt
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# Pharma Confiance
pharmacie viagra generique: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Jetzt [url=https://pharmajetzt.com/#]PharmaJetzt[/url] PharmaJetzt
mijn apotheek medicijnen: internetapotheek spanje – MedicijnPunt
shopaptheke [url=http://pharmajetzt.com/#]online apotheken gГјnstig[/url] apotheke versandkostenfrei ab 10 euro
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# mebendazole pharmacy
acheter ozempic sans ordonnance [url=https://pharmaconfiance.shop/#]pharmacie en ligne france avec ordonnance[/url] Pharma Confiance
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# Pharma Jetzt
shop apotheje: Pharma Jetzt – shop apotheke online bestellen
acheter les 38 fleurs de bach [url=https://pharmaconfiance.shop/#]Pharma Confiance[/url] comprimГ© ketoprofene
https://medicijnpunt.com/# apotheek webshop
ivermectin scabies pharmacy: vyvanse online pharmacy – PharmaConnectUSA
PharmaJetzt [url=https://pharmajetzt.com/#]apotheke onlin[/url] inline apotheke
Pharma Jetzt: shop apotheke versandkosten – shop appotheke
PharmaConnectUSA [url=http://pharmaconnectusa.com/#]PharmaConnectUSA[/url] Pharma Connect USA
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# shop apotheke versandapotheke versandkostenfrei
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – pharmacie de garde aujourd’hui montpellier
pharmacie pas chГЁre [url=http://pharmaconfiance.com/#]Pharma Confiance[/url] pilule du lendemain chien pharmacie
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# online pharmacy generic valtrex
percocet indian pharmacy: PharmaConnectUSA – propecia pharmacy direct
Pharma Jetzt [url=http://pharmajetzt.com/#]pille danach apotheke online[/url] PharmaJetzt
PharmaJetzt: ahop apotheke – online apitheke
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – metronidazole chat
https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/# Pharma Connect USA
Pharma Confiance [url=https://pharmaconfiance.shop/#]Pharma Confiance[/url] Pharma Confiance
Pharma Connect USA [url=https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/#]target pharmacy store locator[/url] no rx needed pharmacy
pharma apotheek: medicijnen kopen zonder recept – apotheken
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
holandia apteka internetowa: medicatie apotheker – MedicijnPunt
Pharma Confiance [url=https://pharmaconfiance.com/#]Pharma Confiance[/url] Pharma Confiance
onlien apotheke: PharmaJetzt – PharmaJetzt
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# Pharma Jetzt
flagyl mycose [url=http://pharmaconfiance.com/#]Pharma Confiance[/url] produits caudalie pas cher