Juvenile Justice: Supreme Court Orders Release of Death Row Convict After 5 Years of Incarceration

Case Reference: Karan v State of Madhya Pradesh, 2023

Decided on 03-03-2023

Introduction

Welcome to the official blog of the Law Offices of Kr. Vivek Tanwar Advocate and Associates, where we are dedicated to providing litigation support services for matters related to the Juvenile Justice Act. In today’s blog post, we aim to shed light on the prevailing issues surrounding the Juvenile Justice Act, the legal framework for their protection, and the steps we can take as a society to combat these acts. Join us as we explore this critical subject and empower you with the knowledge to protect your rights and safety.

In a recent landmark decision, the Supreme Court of India has directed the release of a death row convict who had been incarcerated for more than 5 years in a case involving the kidnap, rape, and murder of a minor. The Court, while upholding the conviction of the appellant, set aside the death sentence and ordered his immediate release. This ruling stems from a case where the appellant had claimed juvenility and sought the benefits available under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection) Act, 2015 (J.J. Act, 2015).

Background

The appellant had challenged the order passed by the division bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, which had affirmed the death sentence awarded by the Trial Court. The charges against the appellant included offenses under Section 363, 376(2)(i), 302, and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), as well as Section 5(m)/6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO). The appellant argued that the sentence awarded under Section 9(2) of the J.J. Act, 2015 should not be enforced. Additionally, he had already undergone more than 5 years of incarceration, whereas Section 18 of the J.J. Act, 2015 allows for a juvenile below 16 years to be awarded a maximum of 3 years of stay in a special home for heinous offenses.

The Court’s Examination

The Supreme Court bench, comprised of B.R. Gavai, Vikram Nath, and Sanjay Karol, JJ., carefully examined the case. They considered the report and material evidence presented before the Trial Court, along with the oral evidence of the appellant’s current and former teachers and guardian. Based on this evidence, the bench concluded that the appellant was indeed aged 15 years, 4 months, and 20 days on the date of the incident.

Interpretation of Juvenile Justice Act

The bench then analyzed the relevant provisions of the J.J. Act, 2015. Section 9 of this act states that a person who was established to be a child on the date of the offense can avail the benefits under the act, even after the case has been decided or the person has attained majority. Sub-section (3) of this section stipulates that if an inquiry determines that a person was a child on the date of the offense, the Court must forward the child to the Juvenile Justice Board (JJB) for appropriate orders. Moreover, any sentence imposed by the Court is deemed to have no effect in such cases.

Section 18 of the J.J. Act, 2015 sets a maximum punishment period of 3 years for a juvenile, with an emphasis on providing reformative services, including education, skill development, counseling, and psychiatric support. However, the appellant had already served 5 years of incarceration, which was deemed illegal by the Court.

Resolution of Key Legal Issues

The Supreme Court examined critical legal issues that arose in the case, including:

  1. Status of Conviction and Sentence: The Court clarified that a finding of juvenile status after conviction does not invalidate the conviction itself. Instead, it only renders the sentence ineffective. This interpretation preserves the jurisdiction of the regular Sessions Court, ensuring that it can continue to oversee the case.
  2. Inquiry by Juvenile Justice Board: The Court ruled that a lack of inquiry by the JJB does not automatically vitiate the conviction. The merits of the conviction can still be examined, but any sentence exceeding the limits set by the J.J. Act, 2015, must be amended.
  3. Continuation of Proceedings: The Court emphasized that proceedings pending before any Board or Court on the date of the commencement of the J.J. Act, 2015, must continue as if the Act had not been enacted. This provision ensures the continuity of cases and preserves the integrity of the legal process.

Supreme Court’s Legal Interpretation

A full bench of the Supreme Court, comprising Justices B.R. Gavai, Vikram Nath, and Sanjay Karol, addressed the appellant’s claims and examined the relevant legal provisions. The Court emphasized the fundamental purpose of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, which is to safeguard the rights and liberties of juvenile offenders and facilitate their reintegration into mainstream society through the imposition of lenient sentences.

The Court referred to Section 9 of the J.J. Act, 2015, which grants individuals who were children at the time of the offense the right to avail themselves of the Act’s benefits even after their case has been decided or they have reached adulthood. Sub-section (3) of this provision stipulates that if an inquiry determines that the accused was a child at the time of the offense, the Court must refer the matter to the Juvenile Justice Board (JJB) for appropriate orders. In cases where a sentence has already been imposed, that sentence is to be considered null and void.

Conclusion

In a significant decision, the Supreme Court of India upheld the conviction of the appellant but set aside the death sentence, ordering his immediate release. This ruling underscores the central objective of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, which is to safeguard the rights of juvenile offenders and facilitate their reintegration into society through the imposition of shorter sentences. The Court’s interpretation of the Act ensures that the justice system can effectively address cases involving juveniles, promoting a fair and compassionate approach to juvenile offenders.

We are a law firm in the name and style of Law Offices of Kr. Vivek Tanwar Advocate and Associates at Gurugram and Rewari. We are providing litigation support services for matters related to the Juvenile Justice Act.

14 Replies to “Supreme Court Deems Extended Incarceration Illegal and Upholds Juvenile Rights”

  1. Информационная статья предлагает всесторонний обзор ситуации, с учетом разных аспектов и аргументов.

  2. Etwa 85 Spielautomaten des Casinos Innsbruck befinden sich im Jackpot Café, mehr als 110
    Automatenspiele sind im klassischen Spielsaal zu finden. Was Turniere betrifft,
    gibt es für Pokerspieler mehr Angebote in Innsbruck.
    In dieser Spielbank werden oft verschiedene Turniere und Meisterschaften in Kartenspielen organisiert.
    Es ist wichtig zu beachten, dass nur Personen über 18 Jahren im Casino spielen können.
    In den österreichischen Casinos der Casinos Austria AG warten Roulette, Blackjack,
    Baccarat, Poker und Geldspielautomaten sowie weitere Gewinnspiele auf Sie.
    Der Glücksspielbereich bietet eine Vielzahl von Automaten (Easy Roulette, Tropical
    Stud Poker, Multi-Roulette) und Tischspielen – American Roulette, Blackjack, Punto Banco, Baccarat, Texas Hold’em, Omaha.
    Pokerspieler können im Casino Innsbruck an Freitagen und Samstagen Cash Games spielen. Egal, ob
    du an einem Roulette-Tisch spielen oder einfach nur etwas essen und trinken willst – im Casino Innsbruck erlebst du garantiert deinen perfekten Abend.
    Es ist ein Ort voller Tradition und Vergnügen, an dem man Roulette,
    Blackjack, Poker und viele weitere Live Casino Spiele spielen kann.
    Jahrhundert wurde das Spielen im Casino Innsbruck noch populärer und es gab viele
    spezialisierte Spielsalons für verschiedene Arten von Glücksspielen.
    Besonders spannend sind die Blackjack-Turniere, die
    regelmäßig stattfinden und Spieler aus der gesamten Region anziehen. Wertgutscheine zum Spielen können online
    ausgedruckt werden. Eine der Hauptattraktionen war ein Gewinnspiel mit einem Hauptpreis von 2.500 Euro.
    In unserem Beitrag schauen wir uns das bekannte Glücksspielhaus etwas näher an. Hier können die Besucher sich vom stressigen Alltag erholen und spannende
    Glücksspiele genießen.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/wazamba-casino-promo-code-ihr-weg-zu-spannenden-belohnungen/

  3. ThunderPick offers a unique and intuitive user interface, making navigation seamless for bettors and players alike.

    The robust loyalty program rewards players with exclusive benefits, enhancing
    their overall experience. The casino boasts over 4000 pokies and
    utilizes Evolution Gaming for its live casino rooms.
    Gambling can become addictive, so it’s important to set limits and
    get professional support if you need help. This guide shares
    my journey, packed with honest reviews, expert opinions,  insider tips, and everything I needed
    to play with confidence. Establishing loss limits and taking
    regular breaks are crucial strategies for preventing gambling-related
    harm.
    These bodies ensure that the casino follows strict rules.
    I began by checking if the casino has a valid
    license from a trusted authority. My curiosity about digital gambling led me to test platforms.
    Always remember to play for fun, stay safe, and gamble responsibly.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/top-online-casinos-with-instant-withdrawal-payouts-2025/

  4. by yuatutlof 1 week ago

    The maximum win reaches an impressive amount of 375,000 AUD. The game also features an advanced autoplay with a turbo mode. In all cases, free spins are eligible to play the Johnny Cash game by BGaming. You need to spend all the free spins within 5 days. Otherwise, they will disappear. With a scorecast you are placing a bet on one of the following, the progressive jackpots and the spectacular variety of slots and live casino games is what helps AuSlots rank amongst the best sites in Australia. Fast Pay Casino No Deposit Bonus for Australians – Get Your 15 Free Spins! Australian players love the Dragon Link pokie series because of the excellent graphics, audio and exciting gameplay. On top of that, a progressive jackpot split across four pokies as well as the bonus features make it a favourite.
    https://druyogametsaskia.nl/how-much-of-a-scam-is-plinko-uk-player-opinions/
    These two electronic wallets are also highly convenient and easy to use, total bets and total losses for that period. On Tuesday, with a 40x wagering requirement. Stand out titles in the slots category include titles such as, but the quality of the few games that are available are simply superb. Weve got to be honest upfront – becoming a professional blackjack player or slots savant is not the best way to go about things, and BGO closed its doors for good. One design element in this 15 Dragon Pearls pokie review we were pleased about was that its paytable displays how much can be won for symbol combinations based on your bet size. The above table, for example, shows the dollar-value wins based on a $1 per spin bet. In 15 Dragon Pearls, you will find 25 paylines that will give you multiple opportunities to make a winning combination with each spin. You have to match at least 3 symbols on a payline to receive a payout.

  5. by pyxltijcu 5 days ago

    Posts Bombastic casino app login | Thunderkick, founded in the 2012, is actually a fairly the fresh developer that have head office inside Stockholm, Sweden. Common gambling enterprises Thunderkick Online game + a hundred 100 percent free revolves Thunderkick Ports Guide Summer 2025 As its name implies, Really of Miracle is an online slot one to… Connect with us Of internet casino campaigns, the greater guaranteeing the main benefit music, the greater amount of you ought to become familiar with the fresh terms and conditions. Considering so it, internet casino offers can also be produce moderate advantages, however it is always negligible, and a lot more have a tendency to than simply not, the newest gambling enterprise will get a way to earn from the a lot of time work at. For many who’re willing to are their give during the Gates from Olympus 1000 the real deal currency, there are some best-rated casinos on the internet where you are able to enjoy so it exciting position.
    https://atsonproducts.in/1054/playfina-casino-game-review-spinning-the-reels-down-under/
    The Gates of Olympus login features a high quality visual design and exciting theme. This machine is wrapped in the atmosphere of ancient Greece, recreating the majestic image of Mount Olympus. The background is decorated with flaming columns in the purple sky, and Zeus floating in the air not only adds beauty to the project, but also plays an important role during the game. It looks like Javascript isn’t enabled in your browser. Please enable it in order to fill out this form. The only thing is required is the registration of your account, or cartoons. From classic table games like blackjack and roulette to popular slot machines and video poker, players can also take advantage of bonuses and promotions offered by online casinos. NetEnt jackpots are known as the biggest In the industry, exciting gameplay.

  6. by ombtdfmln 4 days ago

    gates-of-olympus.tv3.2 The Gates of Olympus slot is no mere mortal machine. It’s a masterwork, blessed with Pragmatic Play’s signature gameplay and radiant graphics. Towering beside the reels, Zeus himself looms like a brooding deity (trust me, I know the look). Should your offerings please him, he might smite the screen with a random multiplier to bless your win. Sign In If you like high-volatility slots with avalanche mechanics, this is a sound pick. Gates of Olympus plays on a 6×5 grid with symbols paying anywhere on the reels, uses a Tumble mechanic for chain wins, and leans on base-game and bonus multipliers that can climb up to 500x. It offers a 5,000x max win and an RTP of 96.50%. Sign In As in the hit original, multiplier symbols can strike with random values of between 2x and 500x on any spin in the base game or bonus game.
    https://www.emmadercourt.com/betzino-by-spribe-a-fresh-casino-experience-for-uk-players/
    This slot is themed on Greek mythology. The theme music is filled with harps, bells and dark undertones. This reminds players that although they are at a heavenly gate, they haven’t gotten in just yet. Help Up against reels of precious gems and mysterious artifacts, players will face a trial to enter the heavenly kingdom. The violet sky seems temptingly just beyond the gates. Match 8-30 symbols anywhere on the grid to win. Multiplier symbols can land on any spin or tumble, boosting wins by up to 500x. If more than one multiplier symbol lands, their values are added together and applied to the total win. Match 8-30 symbols anywhere on the grid to win. Multiplier symbols can land on any spin or tumble, boosting wins by up to 500x. If more than one multiplier symbol lands, their values are added together and applied to the total win.

  7. by fnizdmbuo 4 days ago

    Book of Dead tem uma RTP de 96,21%. Isto significa que 96,21% do dinheiro jogado pelos jogadores é devolvido como ganho, o que é bom para o campo. Você pode jogar Book of Dead em qualque cassino online novo ou até em algum velho cassino online. Outro recurso disponível é o de rodadas grátis no Book of Dead. Para consegui-las, o processo é bastante simples, já que basta obter três ou mais símbolos scatter, dentro de uma única rodada. Então, nesse caso, são disponibilizados mais 10 giros grátis. Lembrando que a função pode ser reativada, caso outros três scatters surjam na rodada extra. The Book of Dead é um slot online Play’n GO com um total de 10 linhas de pagamento personalizáveis e um layout de 5 cilindros e 3 linhas. A aposta mais baixa é simplesmente 1p, e o jogo também é compatível com dispositivos móveis. Uma rodada de rodadas grátis com um símbolo em expansão é um dos bônus e recursos do cassino.
    http://www.littledean.nl/review-do-betonred-o-fascinio-do-jogo-de-casino-para-jogadores-em-portugal/
    Em breve, será redirecionado para o site do casino. Aguarde. Se utilizar algum software de bloqueio de anúncios, verifique as definições. Nesta página, você encontrará todos os Jogos de Casino grátis que oferecemos aqui no Temple of Slots. Você pode começar conferindo nossas recomendações ou usar os filtros disponíveis para encontrar exatamente aquilo que procura. Pode filtrar o jogo por categoria, fornecedor e ou tema para limitar sua busca e exibir apenas o tipo de jogo específico que deseja jogar. E, é claro, se você tem em mente o título de um jogo específico, pode buscá-lo diretamente sem ter que navegar pela abundância de jogos oferecidos. SLOTS | NATAL | ZEUS | MULTIPLICADORES | GIROS GRÁTIS | 1000X | 4WIN.BET.BR This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data.

  8. by hhbaxlmpf 4 days ago

    (09:35 PM-11:50 PM) Players of all Satta Matka games, including those who play Rajdhani Night online, are drawn to this betting platform for several exhilarating reasons. Gamblers all over the world, whether they are novices or expert gamblers, will be capable of achieving a big win by playing the Rajdhani Night game or any other Satta Matka game online using the DPBoss Satta Matka betting platform. Pannel:- 111sattamatka Satta Matka Market is India’s leading website providing the quickest sattamatka outcome, experienced in Satta Matka game. Our services include free Satta Matka Trick and Tips for Kalyan Matka and Disawar Satta King, as well as satta matka graphs, online play, tips and more. Our team of experts strive to help you recoup your losses quickly through our proposals such as Free Satta Matka Tips and Kalyan Bazar Tips. We are known as India’s best Matka DpBoss portal site, here to deliver updates on all sorts of Satta Market like Kalyan Bazar, Milan, Rajdhani, Time Bazaar, Main and the most current charts. Stay tuned with us for more live updates on the Satta market!
    https://designsynergies.net/review-of-magius-casino-a-top-choice-for-australian-players/
    The Tumble Feature is a random but exciting feature of Gates of Olympus online slot. When you create winning combinations in a single spin, all the symbols part of that combo will disappear from your screen, and empty positions will fill up again through a tumbling effect. This process creates new combinations each time. Go on a legendary adventure on all of your favourite iOS and Android devices as Gates of Olympus is fully compatible on all mobile devices. Play in seamless portrait or landscape mode with all features stayin gon-screen at all times including the paytable, bet levels, and all-important spin button. The higher-paying symbols are valuable artifacts.The goblet pays 12x your bet for 12 of a kind, the ring pays 15x, the hourglass pays 25x, and the crown pays 50x. The game also features high volatility, indicating that while wins may not occur as frequently, they can be significant when they do. With a maximum potential payout of 5,000 times your stake, Gates of Olympus offers the chance for big wins.

  9. by mxojetony 3 days ago

    Mottok prisen for Årets spilleautomatleverandør ved IGA Gaming Awards i 2023, og har vunnet en rekke andre priser for fremragende spill. Høydepunktet på Gates of Olympus er en saftig bonusrunde med free spins, men vi skal heller ikke glemme å nevne multiplikatorsymbolene, som dukker opp både der og i hovedspillet. Anastasios: Målet er å skape unike og spennende spillopplevelser for spillerne. Pragmatic Play har laget spillerfavoritter som Gates of Olympus, Sugar Rush, Sweet Bonanza og de populære spillene i Big Bass– og The Dog House-seriene. Nye spill tar sikte på å bygge videre på suksessen fra disse og andre spill, samtidig som de introduserer nye temaer og mekanismer. Fokuset er å ta det spillerne allerede elsker og gi dem enda mer. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data.
    https://newachieversacademy.com/2025/12/23/anmeldelse-av-instant-casino-en-ny-spennende-opplevelse-for-norske-spillere/
    Generelt sett bør man ikke forvente at gevinstene dukker opp særlig ofte på Gates of Olympus, siden automaten er svært volatil. Når du en sjelden gang vinner, er imidlertid premiene ofte ganske store. Omtrent 95,5 % av innsatsen blir tilbakebetalt over tid. Gates of Olympus er en videreutvikling av Pragmatic Play sin superhit Sweet Bonanza. Vi finner ihvertfall: Scatter Pays som byr på gevinster uansett hvor de like symbolene havner, vi ser at vinnende kombinasjoner forsvinner for så å bli erstattet av fallende symboler og som en sukkerbit finnes det til og med multiplikatorer i grunnspillet. Det første vi må nevne, når det kommer til slot funksjoner på Gates of Olympus spilleautomat, er Pay Anywhere. Det er ingen innsatslinjer eller gevinstlinjer på automaten. Du har heller ikke Mega Ways eller Ways to Win. Her har du Pay Anywhere. Dette betyr at du ikke trenger å fokusere på hvor symbolene lander etter et spinn. Det som betyr noe er hvor mange like symboler du klarer å lande.

  10. by qbyifhhaw 2 days ago

    You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. At Fanatics Casino, the minimum bet for table games varies based on the particular game. Most blackjack and roulette games start at $1. Video poker betting starts at $0.10, while craps has a $0.50 minimum bet. Nearly all legal real money online casinos provide players with a variety of slots, table games and live dealer games. The specific number and types of games always will vary, depending on which online casino you are looking at. The Turbo Games teams place great importance on transparency with our community players. On the Vortex game, we applied an RTP of 95.00% and medium volatility, ensuring fairly regular returns on your bets on the Vortex elements reel ! This means that we apply a 5% margin, which funds the development of our upcoming games and compensates our partners.
    https://malikjain.com/mines-by-spribe-a-thrilling-casino-game-review/
    The Sugar Rush 1000 RTP rate is 96.53%. Whilst the original RTP was 97.5%, Pragmatic Play has since reduced it to 96.53% which is still above the industry average of 96% for an online slot game. You’ll also find there are 95.5% and 94.% RTP alternatives which may be used at your chosen slot site(s). Check by opening the Paytable. Sheldon is an experienced content writer focusing on casinos, sports betting, and crypto. He joined Cointelegraph in 2024, bringing nearly a decade of experience in writing in-depth casino reviews, betting guides, and sports predictions. Based in the United Kingdom, Sheldon holds a Master’s degree in English Literature from the University…… Our Picks. Your experience. Enjoy. With all our online casino games available on mobile, you can enjoy a few spins on our Slots through your device. Our mobile-friendly platform means the gameplay is seamless, not only making your experience as interactive as possible but also ensuring our games are available on demand.

  11. by oeurdeogd 1 day ago

    Satta Matka Market is India’s leading website providing the quickest sattamatka outcome, experienced in Satta Matka game. Our services include free Satta Matka Trick and Tips for Kalyan Matka and Disawar Satta King, as well as satta matka graphs, online play, tips and more. Our team of experts strive to help you recoup your losses quickly through our proposals such as Free Satta Matka Tips and Kalyan Bazar Tips. We are known as India’s best Matka DpBoss portal site, here to deliver updates on all sorts of Satta Market like Kalyan Bazar, Milan, Rajdhani, Time Bazaar, Main and the most current charts. Stay tuned with us for more live updates on the Satta market! First You Have To Know About Kalyan Matka And Kalyan Result Then You Can Join Our Kalyan Matka Open Company And Get Fastest Matka Result In Our Kalyan Matka Tips, We Also Surprising Give You Some Important Informative Things Those Are Kalyan Open, Kalyan Night Chart, Kalyan Panel Chart Free, Kalyan Day Open Leak, For All Our Valuable And Sincere Costumers So These Are Helping You For Know The Results In Kalyan, Satta Kalyan Matka Result.
    https://merica77.net/just-casino-game-review-a-thrilling-experience-for-new-zealand-players/
    वीकली स्पेशल डिस्काउंट सिर्फ VIP यूज़र्स के लिए। However, the satta is not legal in India but people prefer the game to play illegally. The craze of the game is increasing day by day to play the SattaMatka online or offline. Matka results can be checked through various online platforms or websites that are totally dedicated to Satta Matka games. Various formats of Matka gaming results are declared on these platforms for ease. We provide Final ank for all markets on daily basis. We are always there for the players to help them win games. SRIDEVI DAY NIGHT, TIME BAZAR, MADHUR DAY NIGHT, MILAN DAY NIGHT, RAJDHANI DAY NIGHT, KALYAN DAY NIGHT, MAIN BAZAR BUMPER DHAMAKA OFFER ACHUK JODI PAR KAMAO LAKHON 100% FIX 1 JODI 2 PATTI.

  12. by pghbckpfp 2 hours ago

    Pier propose des critiques perspicaces et actualisées sur les casinos en ligne, en mettant l’accent sur les dernières tendances en matière de jeux. Connu pour son attention méticuleuse aux détails et son engagement à la précision, son contenu se distingue par son caractère à la fois informatif et engageant. Avec une connaissance approfondie des machines à sous vidéo et des jeux d’argent, Pier transmet son expertise avec clarté, rendant les nuances des jeux en ligne accessibles et agréables pour les nouveaux joueurs comme pour les joueurs expérimentés. COPYRIGHT © 2015 – 2025. Tous droits réservés à Pragmatic Play, un investissement de Veridian (Gibraltar) Limited. Tout le contenu présent sur ce site ou intégré par référence est protégé par les lois internationales sur le droit d’auteur.
    https://marissalawson116.amebaownd.com/posts/58353722
    Plus simplement, on peut considérer que le vortex est un sort qui n’a pas de cible. Tu le lances dans une direction, et tu regardes ce qui se passe. Si ça touche une unité, et que ça provoque un test de panique, on est plutôt dans le cas où tu dois fuit à l’opposé de l’ennemi le plus proche, et non à l’opposé du lanceur de sort… Cf. mon exemple amusant en début de message 🙂 Plus simplement, on peut considérer que le vortex est un sort qui n’a pas de cible. Tu le lances dans une direction, et tu regardes ce qui se passe. Si ça touche une unité, et que ça provoque un test de panique, on est plutôt dans le cas où tu dois fuit à l’opposé de l’ennemi le plus proche, et non à l’opposé du lanceur de sort… Cf. mon exemple amusant en début de message 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.