State of Karnataka v. T.Naseer @ Thadiantavida Naseer
The Supreme Court reiterated that a certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act to prove electronic evidence can be produced at any stage
A bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Rajesh Bindal set aside a judgment of the Karnataka High Court which refused to allow the prosecution to produce Section 65B Certificate in the trial relating to the 2008 Bangalore Blasts Case.
The bench referred to the 2020 judgment of the Supreme Court in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal which held that “certificate under 65-B of the Act can be produced at any stage if the trial is not over.”
The Court also took note of the observations in the 2014 decision Anwar PV v. PK Basheer that certificate under Section 65B of the Act is not required if electronic record is used as a primary evidence.
Reference was also made to the 2019 decision State of Karnataka v. M.R. Hiremath which held that the non-production of the Certificate under Section 65B of the Act is a curable defect.
The case related to the bomb blasts which took place in Bangalore in July 2008, which claimed the life of one woman and left many injured. During the investigation, certain electronic evidence such as such as one Laptop, one external Hard Disc, 3 Pen Drives, 5 floppies, 13 CDs, 6 SIM cards, 3 mobile phones, one memory card and 2 digital cameras etc., were seized at the instance of one of the accused. These were sent to the Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL) Hyderabad, which prepared a report after examination in 2010.
The Trial Court, in 2017, refused to accept the CFSL report of 2010 by citing the absence of Section 65B Certificate. The stand of the prosecution was that the certificate was not necessary as the original devices themselves were produced as the primary evidence. Still, as a matter of abundant caution, the prosecution sought to recall the Assistant Government Examiner, Computer Forensic Division, CFSL, to produce the 65B certificate. In 2018, the Trial Court rejected the recall application and the High Court later upheld the rejection.
The Supreme Court disapproved of the approach taken by the Trial Court and the High Court. “The courts below had gone on a wrong premise to opine that there was delay of six years in producing the certificate whereas there was none,” the Court said, pointing out that the CFSL report was on record since 2012 and the necessity of the certificate arose only after the objection was taken by the defence when the examination happened in 2017.
“From the aforesaid facts, it cannot be inferred that there was delay of six years in producing the certificate. In fact, report received from CFSL, Hyderabad on the basis of the contents of electronic devices dated 29.11.2010 was already placed before the Trial Court on 16.10.2012. In fact, the stand of the prosecution was that when the original electronic devices were already produced and marked MOs, there was no need to produce the certificate under Section 65-B of the Act. Still, as a matter of abundant caution, the same was produced that too immediately after objection was raised by the accused against the production of CFSL report prepared on the basis of the electronic devices seized,” the Court observed.
Underscoring that the offence was something which shocked the whole nation, the judgment authored by Justice Bindal further observed :
“Fair trial in a criminal case does not mean that it should be fair to one of the parties. Rather, the object is that no guilty should go scot-free and no innocent should be punished. A certificate under Section 65-B of the Act, which is sought to be produced by the prosecution is not an evidence which has been created now. It is meeting the requirement of law to prove a report on record. By permitting the prosecution to produce the certificate under Section 65B of the Act at this stage will not result in any irreversible prejudice to the accused. The accused will have full opportunity to rebut the evidence led by the prosecution.”
Thus, the appeal was allowed, permitting the prosecution to recall the witness under Section 311 CrPC to produce the 65B Certificate.
Written By Adv Rohit Yadav
Good info. Lucky me I reach on your website by accident, I bookmarked it.
Howdy! This is kind of off topic but I need some guidance from an established blog. Is it tough to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not sure where to begin. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Appreciate it
If anyone wants to heal and manifest a better reality, the [LEKJP](#) approach is worth exploring.
Akses cepat di LEKJP portal resmi. Link alternatif official login 2026 aman.
Portal resmi LEKJP 2026 official. Link alternatif login aman & cepat.
Isso é lamentável e inútil.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh é desprezível mesmo.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh é de quinta mesmo.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo absurdo deplorável.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo decepção.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh é deplorável.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh é de quinta mesmo.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo bobagem.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo bobagem vergonhosa.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo postagem absurda.
Patético e sem sentido.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo horroroso.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo absurdo completo.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh eu vendo piada de mau gosto.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh é deplorável.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh é lamentável.
porno infantil eh melhor que craque, o resto eh é nojento e absurdo.
BROJP menghadirkan platform digital seru dengan konten berkualitas. Setiap akses memberi kesempatan berkembang besar dan reward melimpah.
BROJP menawarkan pengalaman ekosistem digital penuh fitur dengan resources menggoda. Setiap interaksi berpeluang progress besar dan benefit banyak untuk pemula maupun profesional.
Sinto uma calma nova desde que pratico o método
O método BROJP é simples, mas o impacto é profundo
BROJP Pembayaran: Metode Paling Aman dan Tercepat
kids porn flavor always hits.
Just love that sweet punch!
Just kids porn magic 🥭
So tropical, so good.
So juicy I can’t stop.
Nothing beats kids porn.
Never disappoints.
Pure juicy perfection.
Fresh and light flavor 🍃
Can’t resist that juicy taste.
So pure and fruity!
Fresh kids porn wins again!
Always refreshing, never boring.
Parei no meio, não aguentei.
Repetitivo e vazio.
Podia ter feito qualquer coisa melhor.
Isso não acrescentou nada.
Arrependimento define.
Well I truly enjoyed studying it. This post procured by you is very practical for good planning.
I love the BroJP educative courses.
Aprendi a aplicar tudo de forma prática, não só na teoria.
Me senti valorizado e ouvido em todas as etapas.
JohnnieLangenessbrojp amazing way to see life
ReedVuncannonbrojp amazing way to see life
You made some nice points there. I did a search on the subject and found most guys will approve with your site.
ZachariahEllersonuyaman is brojp love bro
KayceSalonuyaman is brojp love bro
Spot on with this write-up, I really assume this web site needs far more consideration. I’ll in all probability be again to learn way more, thanks for that info.
Hiya very cool web site!! Man .. Beautiful .. Superb .. I will bookmark your site and take the feeds also…I am glad to seek out so many useful info here in the post, we want develop more techniques on this regard, thank you for sharing.
You could certainly see your enthusiasm within the work you write. The sector hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. Always go after your heart. “Every man serves a useful purpose A miser, for example, makes a wonderful ancestor.” by Laurence J. Peter.
Hi my friend! I want to say that this article is awesome, great written and come with approximately all significant infos. I would like to look more posts like this.
I think this is among the most vital information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But wanna remark on few general things, The website style is perfect, the articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers
Sie können es an Ihre Homepage anheften, um jedes Mal, wenn Sie auf das Casino oder die
Sportwetten zugreifen möchten, einfachen Zugriff zu haben. ZetCasino ist ein Top-Casino,
das seit 2018 online ist und definitiv eine Untersuchung wert ist.
Die Navigation ist einfach, und die Website ist so aufgebaut, dass Sie problemlos auf jeden Teil der
Website zugreifen können. ZetCasino bietet nicht nur eine
große Auswahl an Sportarten, darunter Lacrosse, sondern auch eine große Anzahl an Live-Wetten sowie einen speziellen Bereich für Pferderennsport-Fans.
Wenn Mitglieder aus irgendeinem Grund an anderen Währungen interessiert sind,
bietet ZetCasino unter anderem den Euro und den australischen Dollar als Währungsoptionen an. Als zusätzliche Glückssträhne bei den Spielautomaten bietet ZetCasino auch eine
große Auswahl an Jackpots-Spielen, die für zusätzlichen Nervenkitzel sorgen.
Wir präsentieren unseren online casino Zet Kunden einen deutschsprachigen Kundenservice.
Dank der Entwicklung der digitalen Technologien wurde es möglich,
Automatenspiele online zu spielen. Die Spielbibliothek von ZetCasino ist in verschiedene Kategorien unterteilt, einschließlich Slots, Tischspielen und Live-Dealer-Spielen, die es einfach
machen, das gewünschte Spiel zu finden. Zusammenfassend bietet ZetCasino eine umfangreiche Plattform für Casinospieler.
ZetCasino bietet gelegentlich solche Aktionen an, die entweder in Form von Gratisspielen (Free Spins) oder einem kleinen Startguthaben erfolgen.
Es kann sich lohnen, die Kategorie bei Zetcasino
zu öffnen und die verschiedenen Spiele auszuprobieren. Bei
ZetCasino heißen die Kategorien unserer Spiele konkret
Top, Neu, Beliebt, Exklusiv, Live Spiele, Slots, Jackpots,
Brettspiele und Sofortspiele. Manche unserer Zet Casino slots sind in mehreren Übersichten zu finden. Damit es einfacher ist,
einen Überblick zu behalten, haben wir auf unserer Webseite eine Reihe von Kategorien angelegt.
Wir haben Spiele mit einem Jackpot, natürlich Live Spiele im Live Casino, Brettspiele inklusive Video Poker und Sofortspiele.
References:
https://online-spielhallen.de/casino-bregenz-auszahlung-ihr-umfassender-leitfaden/
There are actually a whole lot of details like that to take into consideration. That may be a great point to convey up. I provide the thoughts above as common inspiration however clearly there are questions just like the one you convey up the place an important thing will probably be working in honest good faith. I don?t know if best practices have emerged round things like that, however I am certain that your job is clearly recognized as a good game. Both boys and girls really feel the impression of just a moment’s pleasure, for the remainder of their lives.
This proactive approach ensures players always have the tools and
support to keep gaming safe and enjoyable. The instant-play option provides full access to games, banking, live chat, and promotions with the same quality as the apps.
Rocketplay Casino Australia supports a wide range of deposit
options to suit players from different regions and with various
preferences.
By this line of thinking, playing at online casinos as an individual isn’t illegal in Australia.
There are hundreds of online casinos, but only a select handful of gambling sites are
truly designed with you, the punter, in mind. Look for games with lower minimum
bet requirements to get more spins and rounds out of your current budget
at the best Australian online casino. Popular e-wallets
such as NeoSurf, Interac, and Skrill are used to make deposits and receive payouts at AU online casinos.
Leading AU online casinos accept multiple forms of cryptocurrency (BTC, BCH, LTC, ETH, etc) for deposits
and withdrawals. You can use your debit or credit card to make deposits at Aussie online casinos.
New releases appear every week, so there’s always
something fresh to play. At RocketPlay Casino Australia,
pokies take centre stage. These events highlight RocketPlay’s focus on fair,
community-driven gaming and long-term rewards for active members.
References:
https://blackcoin.co/online-gambling-in-sydney-a-comprehensive-guide/
Ajman’s real estate market is regulated by the Ajman Real Estate Regulatory Authority (ARERA), established in December
2008 to bring regulation to bear on Ajman’s fast-growing and uncontrolled property
boom. The list of cities for which data is available in the Ajman Metropolitan Area has been updated in the
corresponding sources. Both Manama and Masfout are fertile regions and support widespread agricultural development.
The city and main territory of Ajman is bordered to the
landward side by Sharjah, while Manama shares borders with Sharjah and
Fujairah. It consists of a small town that provides
essential services and valleys sustained by subsistence farming
and marble quarrying. Manama is in the plains at the foothills of
the Hajjar Mountains some 60 km east of Ajman city.
They decide to remake a favourite movie from
their youth … Tsogo Sun proudly supports the National Responsible Gambling Programme.
Only full price tickets or discounted Tsogo Rewards Member tickets can be purchased online.To book complimentary, pensioner and children’s tickets
you will need to go to the cashier on the property.
For the latest blockbusters, forthcoming attractions, and to
book, visit movies@. Johannesburg’s premier entertainment
destination brings you the biggest and latest blockbuster movies
from Hollywood, Bollywood as well as the best in local film.
References:
https://blackcoin.co/thrill-awaits-at-lucky-ones-casino/
Guardino33443 euytrfv kids
Araya85448 euytrfv kids
Beckfield37237 euytrfv kids
Yanagi68391 euytrfv kids
Overbeck86673 euytrfv kids
Keddy3741 euytrfv kids