This article explores the interplay between arbitration and insolvency law, specifically focusing on cases where contract breaches involve debtors and creditors. Arbitration has grown in popularity as a way to resolve disputes outside of court, aiming to settle disagreements efficiently. However, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) is a special framework that addresses insolvency, and its specific procedures can limit the scope of arbitration.
Both arbitration and the IBC aim to resolve disputes in a way that balances the interests of parties involved, such as reviving a financially troubled company instead of leading to its dissolution. Although there are no fundamental contradictions between arbitration and insolvency law, their convergence can create uncertainties due to procedural differences.
The article examines situations where an insolvency petition is filed while arbitration proceedings are ongoing, and vice versa, where arbitration proceedings are initiated during the pendency of an insolvency petition. “Pendency” here refers to the period when an insolvency petition is filed but the adjudicating authority (like the National Company Law Tribunal) has not yet made a decision to admit or reject it. This exploration involves analyzing recent court judgments and orders to understand how these situations are handled and the issues that can arise from them.
Arbitrability of Conflicts After Filing a Petition for Insolvency
When deciding whether a dispute can be resolved through arbitration while an insolvency petition is pending, an important legal question arises: does the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) have the authority to refer parties to arbitration? The Supreme Court tackled this issue in the case of Indus Biotech Pvt. Ltd. vs. Kotak India Venture (Offshore) Fund.
The controversy stems from proceedings before the NCLT in Mumbai, where Kotak India Venture filed an insolvency petition against Indus Biotech, claiming default on redeeming preference shares. While this petition was still pending, Indus Biotech submitted an application under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, requesting arbitration.
The NCLT caused a stir by granting Indus Biotech’s request to refer the case to arbitration, even though the insolvency proceeding was ongoing. This raised questions about the NCLT’s authority to refer parties to arbitration during an in rem insolvency proceeding—where the case has broader implications and affects third-party rights.
The Supreme Court clarified the situation in its ruling. It stated that insolvency proceedings become in rem only after the insolvency petition is admitted by the NCLT, at which point it affects third-party rights and takes on a more general impact. Thus, referring to arbitration before the insolvency petition is admitted is permissible. Additionally, the Supreme Court outlined that the NCLT must first assess the merits of the insolvency application before considering the Section 8 arbitration request. The outcome of the insolvency application determines the course of action. If the insolvency petition is admitted and default is proven, arbitration isn’t applicable. However, if no default is found, the parties can pursue arbitration.
The Status regarding the Appointment of an Arbitrator in the Pending Insolvency Proceedings
In the case of Sunflag Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. M/s Poonamchand & Sons, the Bombay High Court clarified whether an arbitrator can be appointed while insolvency proceedings are pending. The court stated that filing an application under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) does not necessarily block the appointment of an arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.
The Applicant argued that there was no dispute about the existence or validity of the arbitration agreement. However, the Respondent countered, saying that since insolvency proceedings had been initiated under Section 7 of the IBC, the appointment of an arbitrator wasn’t valid, citing the IBC’s Section 238, which overrides other laws in cases of conflict.
The Bombay High Court observed that the IBC’s overriding effect under Section 238 only applies if the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) admits the insolvency application. This means that just filing a Section 7 application doesn’t automatically invoke Section 238’s restrictions. Thus, appointing an arbitrator under Section 11(6) remains valid until the NCLT admits the insolvency petition and confirms the default.
The court’s decision aligned with the earlier Supreme Court ruling in Indus Biotech Private Limited v. Kotak India Venture (Offshore) Fund & Ors., which emphasized that the NCLT must first confirm the default to make the insolvency proceeding in rem—affecting all parties. Based on this, the Bombay High Court allowed the Section 11(6) application and appointed a sole arbitrator to resolve the disputes.
Another case, Millennium Education Foundation v. Educomp Infrastructure and School Management Limited, further supported this view. It held that the mere filing of an insolvency petition under Section 9 of the IBC does not block the appointment of an arbitrator under Section 8 of the Arbitration Act. The restriction only applies once the insolvency petition is admitted, and a moratorium is declared.
These judgments have provided guidance on appointing arbitrators while insolvency petitions are pending. However, they leave open questions about what happens when arbitration proceedings are initiated after the NCLT has admitted an insolvency petition and declared a moratorium. This area requires further legal clarification.
Commencing CIRP amidst ongoing Arbitration
Courts and tribunals have examined whether the presence of an arbitration agreement or ongoing arbitration proceedings preclude the submission of an insolvency petition under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). In the case of Reliance Commercial Credit Limited v. Ved Cellulose Ltd., the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) in Mumbai ruled that ongoing arbitration proceedings do not prevent the start of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) under Section 7 of the IBC. Similarly, in Dinesh Chand Jain and Others v. Fabulous Buildcon (P) Ltd. and Others, the NCLT in Delhi concluded that an arbitration clause in an agreement does not bar insolvency proceedings under Section 7 of the IBC.
In another case, M/s. Educomp Infrastructure & School Management Ltd. v. M/s. Millennium Education Foundation, the NCLT in New Delhi admitted an insolvency petition even though arbitration proceedings were ongoing. The tribunal appointed an Interim Resolution Professional (IRP) and declared a moratorium under Section 14 of the IBC, because the corporate debtor was in default of an operational debt. This example shows that the court can admit insolvency petitions even during ongoing arbitration, and the arbitration proceedings cease as a result of the moratorium imposed by Section 14(1)(a).
Thus, having an arbitration agreement or ongoing arbitration proceedings does not automatically prevent the start of insolvency proceedings under the IBC. Courts have taken a practical approach, emphasizing a balance between the interests of corporate debtors and creditors.
However, there is a restriction on initiating CIRP if there’s a pending challenge to an arbitral award under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. In the case of Kishan v. M/s Vijay Nirman Company Pvt. Ltd., the broader interpretation of “dispute” included a challenge to an arbitral award. According to the Supreme Court’s decision in the Mobilox Innovation Case, for a challenge to be considered a “dispute,” it must show a plausible contention requiring further investigation. If a challenge to an arbitral award is pending, the operational debt cannot be treated as undisputed, and CIRP cannot be initiated.
The Supreme Court has emphasized that insolvency processes should not be used to circumvent the adjudicatory processes of other statutes. The court reiterated that Section 238 of the IBC, which grants the IBC supremacy in cases of conflict with other laws, doesn’t apply if there’s no inconsistency between the IBC and the Arbitration Act. Therefore, challenging an arbitral award under Section 34 signals an ongoing dispute, which means the insolvency process for operational debt is not warranted while that dispute is unresolved.
Conclusion
In summary, courts have adopted a balanced approach to reconciling arbitration and insolvency proceedings, ensuring that neither undermines the other. It’s permissible to appoint an arbitrator before an insolvency petition is admitted, and insolvency petitions can proceed even if arbitration is ongoing, though the arbitration ends once the petition is admitted and a moratorium is declared. However, if an arbitral award is being challenged, initiating insolvency proceedings is not allowed, as it indicates a pre-existing dispute.
Despite the priority given to the IBC as a specialized law with the primary aim of preventing corporate failure, arbitration still has its place, with minimal restrictions. This approach helps balance the interests of creditors and debtors, providing a fair process that doesn’t excessively favor one over the other. Ultimately, it reflects a system designed to support both the effective resolution of disputes through arbitration and the orderly management of insolvency to avoid corporate collapse.
This online pharmacy provides a wide range of health products for budget-friendly costs.
Shoppers will encounter all types of drugs for all health requirements.
We strive to maintain high-quality products at a reasonable cost.
Speedy and secure shipping guarantees that your purchase is delivered promptly.
Take advantage of ordering medications online through our service.
https://www.bark.com/en/us/company/vidalista-20/qowDp/
В России сертификация играет важную роль для подтверждения соответствия продукции установленным стандартам. Она необходима как для бизнеса, так и для конечных пользователей. Наличие сертификата подтверждает, что продукция прошла все необходимые проверки. Особенно это актуально для товаров, влияющих на здоровье и безопасность. Прошедшие сертификацию компании чаще выбираются потребителями. Кроме того, сертификация может быть необходима для участия в тендерах и заключении договоров. Таким образом, сертификация способствует развитию бизнеса и укреплению позиций на рынке.
сертификация качества
Swiss watches have long been a benchmark of excellence. Meticulously designed by legendary brands, they combine classic techniques with modern technology.
Every component demonstrate superior workmanship, from hand-assembled movements to high-end finishes.
Investing in a timepiece is a true statement of status. It signifies refined taste and heritage craftsmanship.
Be it a minimalist aesthetic, Swiss watches provide extraordinary beauty that lasts for generations.
https://www.thefamilylegion.se/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=84516
Purchasing medicine from e-pharmacies is far more convenient than shopping in person.
No need to wait in line or think about limited availability.
Online pharmacies allow you to buy what you need with just a few clicks.
Numerous platforms have special deals in contrast to brick-and-mortar pharmacies.
https://eccentrictirade.com/forums/showthread.php?tid=135434
On top of that, you can check various options quickly.
Quick delivery adds to the ease.
What do you think about purchasing drugs from the internet?
На данном ресурсе доступны свежие международные политические новости. Ежедневные публикации помогают оставаться в курсе главных новостей. Вы узнаете о дипломатических переговорах. Объективная аналитика способствуют оценить происходящее. Будьте в центре событий вместе с нами.
https://justdoitnow03042025.com
Поклонники онлайн-казино всегда могут найти актуальное альтернативный адрес онлайн-казино Champion чтобы без проблем запустить любым игровым ассортиментом.
На платформе доступны самые топовые слоты, включая классические, и последние игры от ведущих производителей.
Если официальный сайт временно заблокирован, альтернативная ссылка поможет моментально получить доступ и наслаждаться любимыми слотами.
https://casino-champions-slots.ru
Весь функционал сохраняются, включая открытие профиля, депозиты и вывод выигрышей, а также бонусы.
Заходите через обновленную зеркало, и наслаждаться игрой без блокировок!
This website features a wide selection of slot games, suitable for different gaming styles.
Here, you can discover classic slots, new generation slots, and jackpot slots with stunning graphics and realistic audio.
No matter if you’re a fan of minimal mechanics or prefer engaging stories, you’ll find something that suits you.
http://7000.kiev.ua/image/pages/?kak_pomenyaty_tkany_na_abaghure.html
All games is playable 24/7, with no installation, and fully optimized for both desktop and smartphone.
Apart from the machines, the site provides tips and tricks, bonuses, and user ratings to help you choose.
Sign up, start playing, and enjoy the excitement of spinning!
Здесь вам открывается шанс испытать широким ассортиментом игровых автоматов.
Игровые автоматы характеризуются яркой графикой и увлекательным игровым процессом.
Каждая игра даёт уникальные бонусные раунды, повышающие вероятность победы.
1xbet игровые автоматы
Игра в слоты подходит игроков всех уровней.
Вы можете играть бесплатно, а затем перейти к игре на реальные деньги.
Попробуйте свои силы и окунитесь в захватывающий мир слотов.
На нашем портале вам предоставляется возможность наслаждаться широким ассортиментом игровых слотов.
Слоты обладают яркой графикой и захватывающим игровым процессом.
Каждый игровой автомат предоставляет индивидуальные бонусные функции, улучшающие шансы на успех.
1xbet казино официальный сайт
Слоты созданы для любителей азартных игр всех мастей.
Вы можете играть бесплатно, после чего начать играть на реальные деньги.
Испытайте удачу и насладитесь неповторимой атмосферой игровых автоматов.
This website features plenty of video slots, suitable for different gaming styles.
Right here, you can find retro-style games, modern video slots, and jackpot slots with stunning graphics and dynamic music.
Whether you’re into simple gameplay or prefer bonus-rich rounds, this site has what you’re looking for.
https://lan.by/theme/page/?kakoy_karniz_vybraty_dlya_spalyni.html
Each title is playable anytime, no download needed, and well adapted for both desktop and smartphone.
Besides slots, the site includes tips and tricks, special offers, and player feedback to guide your play.
Join now, jump into the action, and have fun with the excitement of spinning!
На этом сайте вы сможете найти разнообразные игровые слоты в казино Champion.
Коллекция игр содержит классические автоматы и актуальные новинки с захватывающим оформлением и разнообразными функциями.
Любая игра создан для удобной игры как на ПК, так и на мобильных устройствах.
Будь вы новичком или профи, здесь вы сможете выбрать что-то по вкусу.
чемпион регистрация
Автоматы запускаются в любое время и не требуют скачивания.
Кроме того, сайт предлагает программы лояльности и обзоры игр, для удобства пользователей.
Начните играть прямо сейчас и оцените преимущества с казино Champion!
Здесь доступны слоты платформы Vavada.
Каждый пользователь найдёт подходящую игру — от традиционных одноруких бандитов до новейших слотов с бонусными раундами.
Платформа Vavada открывает широкий выбор популярных игр, включая слоты с крупными выигрышами.
Каждый слот доступен круглосуточно и оптимизирован как для компьютеров, так и для планшетов.
вавада регистрация
Игроки могут наслаждаться настоящим драйвом, не выходя из любимого кресла.
Интерфейс сайта проста, что позволяет быстро найти нужную игру.
Начните прямо сейчас, чтобы погрузиться в мир выигрышей!
Данный ресурс — цифровая витрина частного расследовательской службы.
Мы оказываем помощь в решении деликатных ситуаций.
Штат детективов работает с абсолютной конфиденциальностью.
Мы берёмся за наблюдение и разные виды расследований.
Заказать детектива
Любая задача получает персональный подход.
Опираемся на новейшие технологии и действуем в правовом поле.
Если вы ищете ответственное агентство — свяжитесь с нами.
This online store offers a great variety of decorative wall-mounted clocks for any space.
You can browse minimalist and timeless styles to match your interior.
Each piece is hand-picked for its visual appeal and durability.
Whether you’re decorating a functional kitchen, there’s always a fitting clock waiting for you.
vintage retro decorative iron wall clocks
The shop is regularly updated with exclusive releases.
We prioritize quality packaging, so your order is always in good care.
Start your journey to better decor with just a few clicks.
This online service features a large selection of pharmaceuticals for home delivery.
Users can quickly buy needed prescriptions without leaving home.
Our catalog includes everyday treatments and custom orders.
Each item is provided by trusted providers.
https://www.pinterest.com/pin/879609370963831421/
We ensure user protection, with encrypted transactions and on-time dispatch.
Whether you’re looking for daily supplements, you’ll find affordable choices here.
Explore our selection today and enjoy convenient support.
Here, you can discover lots of casino slots from top providers.
Players can try out classic slots as well as modern video slots with high-quality visuals and bonus rounds.
Whether you’re a beginner or a casino enthusiast, there’s always a slot to match your mood.
play aviator
Each title are available 24/7 and optimized for PCs and mobile devices alike.
No download is required, so you can jump into the action right away.
Site navigation is intuitive, making it convenient to browse the collection.
Join the fun, and enjoy the world of online slots!
On this platform, you can discover a wide selection of casino slots from famous studios.
Players can experience retro-style games as well as feature-packed games with stunning graphics and exciting features.
If you’re just starting out or a seasoned gamer, there’s always a slot to match your mood.
casino slots
The games are instantly accessible anytime and compatible with PCs and mobile devices alike.
No download is required, so you can get started without hassle.
The interface is easy to use, making it quick to find your favorite slot.
Register now, and discover the world of online slots!
Were you aware that nearly 50% of people taking prescriptions experience serious medication errors because of lack of knowledge?
Your wellbeing requires constant attention. All treatment options you consider directly impacts your quality of life. Being informed about your prescriptions should be mandatory for optimal health outcomes.
Your health depends on more than following prescriptions. All pharmaceutical products interacts with your body’s chemistry in unique ways.
Remember these life-saving facts:
1. Mixing certain drugs can cause health emergencies
2. Over-the-counter pain relievers have potent side effects
3. Self-adjusting treatment reduces effectiveness
To protect yourself, always:
✓ Research combinations using official tools
✓ Review guidelines in detail when starting any medication
✓ Ask your pharmacist about potential side effects
___________________________________
For professional medication guidance, visit:
https://community.alteryx.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/577245
This online pharmacy offers a broad selection of medications at affordable prices.
Customers can discover various medicines for all health requirements.
Our goal is to keep trusted brands without breaking the bank.
Fast and reliable shipping ensures that your order gets to you quickly.
Experience the convenience of shopping online on our platform.
difference between viagra and cialis