Mahant Prasad Ram Tripathi @ M.P.R. Tripathi vs State Of U.P. Via C.B.I./A.C.B., Lucknow And Another
The Allahabad High Court has decided that a phone call between two accused parties cannot be excluded from evidence because it was recorded illegally. [CBI/A.C.B., Lucknow and Others v. State of U.P. Mahant Prasad Ram Tripathi @ M.P.R. Tripathi] Justice Subhash Vidyarthi made the statement while upholding the trial court’s ruling to keep an accused person in a bribery case behind bars because of a recorded phone conversation.
The accused had disputed the phone conversation’s admission, claiming it was obtained illegally. But the Court dismissed his claim.
The Court declared that whether or not the telephone connection between the two accused parties was lawfully intercepted would not affect the admissibility of the recorded discussion as evidence against the applicant.
The court ruled that the contrary decisions from the Delhi High Court and the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Rayala M. Bhuvaneswari v. Nagaphanender Rayala and Sanjay Pandey v. Directorate of Enforcement, respectively, were inadmissible.
The Delhi High Court held in Sanjay Pandey’s case that “tapping phone lines or recording individuals’ calls without their knowledge is a breach of privacy.”
In a similar decision, the Andhra Pradesh High Court declared that a husband could not listen in on his wife’s conversation and that such evidence could not be presented in court.
The Supreme Court’s legal principles, as established in the 2001 Parliamentary attack case of State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, were allegedly violated by the Allahabad High Court.
Justice Vidyarthi went on to say that the sole criterion that counts when determining whether or not evidence is allowed to be admitted in India is relevancy.
“The law is clear that any evidence can’t be refused to be admitted by the Court on the basis that it was obtained illegally,” the court declared.
Mahant Prasad Ram Tripathi, the former CEO of a Cantonment Board, was facing corruption charges, and the bench was considering a criminal revision plea trial court ruling that denied his request for release.
It is said that Tripathi made a 1.65 lakh rupee demand through board member Shashi Mohan.
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) employed a digital audio recorder to capture the exchange between the two defendants after one of the accused put the phone on speakerphone. During this conversation, the co-accused allegedly told Tripathi that 6% of the amount had been paid.
The CBI claims that Tripathi replied “yes,” and when Mohan tried to carry on the conversation, the former advised him to avoid bringing up the topic and asked to talk to him in person.
Tripathi asked to be dismissed from this corruption case, citing the telephone conversation’s inadmissibility as evidence.
His lawyer claims that Section 5 of the Indian Telegraph Act only permits communication interception under certain conditions and only with a government warrant.
However, the Court declared that in this particular case, the phone call that was recorded would not be considered an interception.
It appears that the message was transferred by one of the accused to the other, who subsequently recorded it using a digital voice recorder, a separate recording device. In these circumstances, is it possible to say that the two accused individuals’ communication was “intercepted”? Based on the word’s straightforward meaning, the Court declared that it seems the transmission was not “intercepted.”
The court rejected the revision application and upheld the trial court’s ruling after noting that other evidence was also used against the accused, including the recording of the phone conversation.
Adv. Khanak Sharma
Trustworthy and reliable, every single visit.
where can i get lisinopril pill
Their loyalty program offers great deals.
865302 796794I enjoy your writing style really enjoying this web site . 428509
821082 189813Wow, suprisingly I never knew this. Maintain up with good posts. 532275
133114 894844Locate out these pointers read on and learn to know how to submit an application performing this which you policy your corporation today. alertpay 546204
249223 13120I truly appreciate this post. Ive been searching all over for this! Thank goodness I located it on Bing. Youve made my day! Thank you once more.. 744331
601301 182613You created some decent points there. I looked on the net for any concern and identified most individuals goes in addition to with all your site. 124195
415782 280774I like this weblog so a lot, saved to my bookmarks . 73568
664218 919911I adore the look of your site. I lately built mine and I was seeking for some style tips and you gave me a couple of. Might I ask you whether you developed the site by youself? 975923
104195 210801Hello there, I discovered your blog by way of Google at the same time as looking for a comparable topic, your website got here up, it seems to be fantastic. Ive bookmarked it in my google bookmarks. 825831
5133 55021Many thanks for sharing this fine piece. Quite interesting ideas! (as always, btw) 961959
813241 228643Jeden Tag stellt man sich die Frage Was Koche Ich Heute?! Zerbrechen Sie sich nicht den Kopf, besuchen Sie uns am besten direkt auf unserer Webseite uns lassen Sie sich inspirieren 824018
146512 3917A really exciting examine, I might possibly not concur entirely, but you do make some truly legitimate points. 633049
261887 594629The when I just read a weblog, Im hoping that this doesnt disappoint me approximately this one. Get real, Yes, it was my method to read, but When i thought youd have something intriguing to state. All I hear is actually a number of whining about something which you could fix really should you werent too busy trying to find attention. 181743
930432 311974Keep up the great piece of work, I read few posts on this internet web site and I believe that your web blog is truly fascinating and contains lots of superb information. 935138
322606 890172The place else could anyone get that kind of info in such a perfect method of writing? 535396
603819 268270Top rated lad speeches and toasts, as properly toasts. could really nicely be supplied taken into consideration generating at the party consequently required to be slightly more cheeky, humorous with instructive on top of this. greatest man speeches funny 100792
145938 360413Hi there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any issues with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing a few months of hard work due to no data backup. Do you have any solutions to stop hackers? 994091
972628 336340Excellent editorial! Would like took pleasure the specific following. Im hoping to learn to read a great deal much more of you. Theres no doubt which you possess tremendous awareness and even imagination. I happen to be quite highly fascinated utilizing this critical details. 54551
59843 77758Some truly good and utilitarian info on this web internet site , likewise I think the style and style holds great features. 974269
926320 148859 There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you created certain nice points in functions also. 896484
795887 670683I was trying to locate this. Truly refreshing take on the information. Thanks a great deal. 702734
489916 941205As I web-site possessor I believe the content material matter here is rattling great , appreciate it for your efforts. You should keep it up forever! Finest of luck. 455256
399069 86880numerous thanks for telling!. Truth is normally the very best vindication against slander. by Abraham Lincoln.. 330207
281333 71591I saw a lot of website but I believe this one has got something unique in it in it 538228
494579 792455As I web-site possessor I believe the content matter here is rattling amazing , appreciate it for your efforts. You need to maintain it up forever! Finest of luck. 877402
704437 616708An intriguing discussion is worth comment. Im sure which you simply write regarding this subject, could possibly not be considered a taboo topic but typically persons are too small to communicate on such topics. To an additional. Cheers 788284
6930 192472Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so a lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I feel which you can do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but instead of that, this really is amazing blog. A amazing read. Ill surely be back. 486605
118804 85408Youre so correct. Im there with you. Your blog is surely worth a read if anyone comes throughout it. Im lucky I did because now Ive obtained a whole new view of this. I didnt realise that this problem was so essential and so universal. You completely put it in perspective for me. 86879
980627 498733Check out our internet site for info about securities based lending and far more. There is details about stock and equity loans as nicely as application forms. 366805
584313 669782Hey, are you having issues together with your hosting? I necessary to refresh the page about million times to get the page to load. Just saying 394163
942551 18721Great web site you got here! Yoo man great reads, post some far more! Im gon come back so greater have updated 757351
387258 199157Excellent post, effectively put together. Thanks. I will be back soon to check out for updates. Cheers 39191
575789 545846This is a very good topic to speak about. Sometimes I fav stuff like this on Redit. This post probably wont do well with that crowd. I will likely be positive to submit something else though. 586096
494241 342189appreciate the effort you put into finding us this information 708890
51822 806891Hiya! awesome blog! I happen to be a everyday visitor to your internet site (somewhat more like addict ) of this web site. Just wanted to say I appreciate your blogs and am searching forward for far more to come! 97791
49096 173111Thank you for your style connected with motive though this details is certain location a new damper within the sale with tinfoil hats. 493934
992015 866231hi this post help me full . .should you want watches males visit my websites is extremely aid you for males watches. .thank man very good job. 434063
804373 311322It is onerous to search out knowledgeable individuals on this topic, however you sound like you already know what you are talking about! Thanks 296867