Harmless Humor or Ableism?: Supreme Court Judgement Clarifies
In a recent supreme court judgement, the bench delivered a crucial judgement distinguishing between ‘disabling and disability humor’.In the case of Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Ltd, this issue was argued in context of the movie ‘Aankh Micholi’. The petitioner did not sought any ban or censorship on the production of this movie but rather guidelines against the filmmakers regarding the provisions of the Rights of the Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 ( Act of 2016) and the composition of the Board and the Advisory panel under the Cinematograph Act 1952. The bench said
“We must therefore, distinguish ‘disabling humour’ that demeans and disparages persons with disability from ‘disability humour’ which challenges conventional wisdom about disability. While disability humour attempts to better understand and explain disability, disabling humour denigrates it.The two cannot be equated in their impact on dignity and on stereotypes about persons with disabilities.”
Recognizing Modern Disability Humor Model
The Court conducted an analysis and found that in the past, humour was frequently employed to mock individuals with disabilities, portraying their situation as tragic or humorous. The medical model, an antiquated perspective, considered disability as a personal misfortune unsuited to comedy. But this viewpoint is out of date. Disability is viewed differently under the modern social model, which views it as a product of societal restrictions as opposed to a personal issue. According to this paradigm, misconceptions regarding impairments result from a lack of information, which is frequently brought on by a lack of representation in popular discourse. The Court observed that people with disabilities are using humour more and more these days to interact with others and share their stories. This has the potential to dispel negative stereotypes and alter public perceptions of disability. Disabled comedians use humour to promote equality by challenging preconceived notions about who is “different” or “less than,” especially when it comes to making fun of themselves.
Therefore the court noted
“ The medical model treats disability as a personal ‘tragedy’ which is by definition, incompatible with humour.This understanding is now obsolete under the social model which views disability as a function of social barriers that disable such individuals.The social model says that stereotypes stem from a lack of familiarity with disability. This lack arises due to inadequate representation and participation of persons with disabilities in dominant discourse. Despite the history and the obsolescence of the medical model, humour is not universally denounced in the context of disability. It is now being increasingly used as a sophisticated literary medium for engagement with the society by persons with disabilities. It familiarises the society with the lived experiences of persons with disability, thereby dispelling prejudicial myths, and sensitizing people. Challenging notions of ‘otherness’ or ‘inferiority’ associated with persons with disability, humour creates an equal space”
Article 19(2) Restrictions
The court said that to determine whether the film was violating the restrictions placed under Article 19(2) we had to look at and consider the overall message of the film, if the same is positive then the language would not constitute a violation under Article 19(2) however if the ‘jokes’ are present just for social exclusion without any positive message it does constitute a violation.
“As long as the overall message of the film justifies the depiction of disparaging language being used against persons with disabilities, it cannot be subjected to restrictions beyond those placed in Article 19(2). However, language that disparages persons with disabilities, marginalises them further and supplements the disabling barriers in their social participation, without the redeeming quality of the overall message of such portrayal must be approached with caution. Such representation is problematic not because it offends subjective feelings but rather, because it impairs the objective societal treatment of the affected groups by society.”
Guidelines set down by the bench
It was contended before the Court that, despite the advisory panel having twenty-five members, one of them might be a member of the mentally or physically challenged part. The petitioner contended that sensitivities would be taken into account during the certification process if there was representation on the advisory panel. S.5(1) of the Cinematograph Act allows the Central Government to establish advisory bodies to determine how films affect the general public. According to S.5(4), the advisory group has the right to evaluate the movie and offer changes to the Censorship Board. The court put forward certain guidelines to be followed-
- Words cultivate institutional discrimination. Terms such as “cripple” and “spastic” have come to acquire devalued meanings in societal perceptions about persons with disabilities. They contribute to the negative self-image and perpetuate discriminatory attitudes and practices in society;
- Language that individualises the impairment and overlooks the disabling social barriers (e.g. terms such as “afflicted”, “suffering”, and “victim”) should be avoided or adequately flagged as contrary to the social model130;
- Creators must check for accurate representation of a medical condition as much as possible. The misleading portrayal of what a condition such as night blindness entails may perpetuate misinformation about the condition, and entrench stereotypes about persons with such impairments, aggravating the disability;
- Persons with disabilities are under-represented. Average people are unaware of the barriers persons with disabilities face. Visual media must reflect their lived experiences. Their portrayal must capture the multitudes of their lived realities, and should not be a uni-dimensional, ableist characterisation;
- Visual media should strive to depict the diverse realities of persons with disabilities, showcasing not only their challenges but also their successes, talents, and contributions to society. This balanced representation can help dispel stereotypes and promote a more inclusive understanding of disability. Such portrayals should reflect the multifaceted lives of persons with disabilities, emphasizing their roles as active community members who contribute meaningfully across various spheres of life. By highlighting their achievements and everyday experiences, media can shift the narrative from one of limitation to one of potential and agency;
- They should neither be lampooned based on myths (such as, ‘blind people bump into objects in their path’) nor presented as ‘super cripples’ on the other extreme. This stereotype implies that persons with disabilities have extraordinary heroic abilities that merit their dignified treatment. For instance, the notion that visually impaired persons have enhanced spatial senses may not apply to everyone uniformly. It also implies that those who do not have such enhanced superpowers to compensate for the visual impairment are somehow less than ideal;
- Decision-making bodies must bear in mind the values of participation. The ‘nothing about us, without us’ principle is based on t
- he promotion of participation of persons with disabilities and equalisation of opportunities. It must be put to practice in constituting statutory committees and inviting expert opinions for assessing the overall message of films and their impact on dignity of individuals under the Cinematograph Act and Rules;131
- The CPRD also requires consultation with and involvement of persons with disabilities in the implementation of measures to encourage portrayal that is consistent with it.132 Collaboration with disability advocacy groups can provide invaluable insights and guidance on respectful and accurate portrayals, ensuring that content aligns with the lived experiences of persons with disabilities; and
- Training and sensitization programs should be implemented for individuals involved in creating visual media content, including writers, directors, producers, and actors. These programs should emphasize the impact of their portrayals on public perceptions and the lived experiences of persons with disabilities. Topics should include the principles of the social model of disability, the importance of respectful language, and the need for accurate and empathetic representation. Regular workshops and collaboration with disability advocacy groups can foster a deeper understanding and commitment to responsible portrayal
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s judgement is a pivotal step toward fostering a more inclusive society where humour can be used responsibly. By distinguishing between ‘disabling’ and ‘disability humour’, the Court has set clear guidelines to ensure that humour does not perpetuate stereotypes or discrimination against persons with disabilities. The guidelines emphasize accurate representation, sensitivity, and the active participation of individuals with disabilities in media creation. This judgement promotes a balance between freedom of expression and the dignity of individuals, encouraging a respectful and informed portrayal of disabilities in visual media.
Contributed by Aditya Gupta (Intern)
OP Jindal Global University, BA LLB
They provide international health solutions at my doorstep.
lisinopril 20 mg what to buy without prescription
Appreciate their commitment to maintaining global healthcare standards.
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Semaglu Pharm
Lipi Pharm Discreet shipping for Lipitor Lipi Pharm
PredniPharm: buy prednisone 10mg – PredniPharm
Lipi Pharm: Affordable Lipitor alternatives USA – does lipitor increase blood pressure
buy prednisone 20mg without a prescription best price Predni Pharm best pharmacy prednisone
http://prednipharm.com/# prednisone pill 20 mg
SemagluPharm: Rybelsus for blood sugar control – Rybelsus for blood sugar control
п»їBuy Rybelsus online USA Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm
FDA-approved Rybelsus alternative: Safe delivery in the US – SemagluPharm
п»їBuy Crestor without prescription: pitavastatin vs rosuvastatin – Crestor Pharm
Order cholesterol medication online LipiPharm is rosuvastatin the same as atorvastatin
crestor blood pressure: Crestor Pharm – CrestorPharm
PredniPharm: prednisone cost 10mg – Predni Pharm
https://lipipharm.shop/# Lipi Pharm
Predni Pharm prednisone 5 mg tablet without a prescription PredniPharm
SemagluPharm: Rybelsus side effects and dosage – is semaglutide safe
cost of prednisone 5mg tablets: medicine prednisone 10mg – PredniPharm
Crestor Pharm Buy cholesterol medicine online cheap should i take crestor at night
10 mg prednisone: Predni Pharm – prednisone 5 tablets
PredniPharm: PredniPharm – prednisone 40 mg price
https://semaglupharm.com/# Affordable Rybelsus price
SemagluPharm drinking on semaglutide Semaglu Pharm
Lipi Pharm: LipiPharm – Lipi Pharm
LipiPharm: FDA-approved generic statins online – LipiPharm
Lipi Pharm Atorvastatin online pharmacy USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery
rosuvastatin medscape: rosuvastatin calcium en espaГ±ol – Crestor Pharm
Predni Pharm: Predni Pharm – prednisone 10mg cost
https://prednipharm.shop/# prednisone 5 mg cheapest
PredniPharm prednisone 10mg tablets prednisone 1 mg daily
Crestor Pharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm
cost of prednisone 10mg tablets 20 mg prednisone tablet prednisone 5mg price
SemagluPharm: how much weight can you lose on semaglutide in 3 months – SemagluPharm
CrestorPharm: Crestor Pharm – Crestor Pharm
generic name of crestor Crestor Pharm CrestorPharm
rosuvastatin photo: CrestorPharm – CrestorPharm
Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews: п»їBuy Rybelsus online USA – Semaglu Pharm
rosuvastatin tendonitis CrestorPharm CrestorPharm
prednisone 60 mg price: PredniPharm – generic over the counter prednisone
side effects crestor vs lipitor: USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery – Lipi Pharm
India Pharm Global cheapest online pharmacy india India Pharm Global
https://indiapharmglobal.shop/# India Pharm Global
Meds From Mexico: reputable mexican pharmacies online – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy: my canadian pharmacy review – pharmacy com canada
India Pharm Global world pharmacy india indian pharmacy paypal
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexico drug stores pharmacies – Meds From Mexico
India Pharm Global: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global
https://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global
Meds From Mexico: Meds From Mexico – Meds From Mexico
India Pharm Global India Pharm Global India Pharm Global
canadian world pharmacy: canadian pharmacy drugs online – northwest canadian pharmacy
top online pharmacy india: India Pharm Global – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
Meds From Mexico mexican rx online mexican mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacy 24h: Canada Pharm Global – canadian pharmacies
https://canadapharmglobal.com/# maple leaf pharmacy in canada
India Pharm Global: reputable indian online pharmacy – top online pharmacy india
india pharmacy mail order top 10 pharmacies in india buy prescription drugs from india
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – buying prescription drugs in mexico
India Pharm Global: buy medicines online in india – india online pharmacy
India Pharm Global world pharmacy india п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
https://medsfrommexico.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican rx online: purple pharmacy mexico price list – medication from mexico pharmacy
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: medication from mexico pharmacy – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
canadian world pharmacy cheapest pharmacy canada best canadian pharmacy
reputable canadian pharmacy: legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy – the canadian drugstore
Meds From Mexico: mexico drug stores pharmacies – Meds From Mexico
pharmacy website india India Pharm Global top online pharmacy india
https://canadapharmglobal.shop/# legitimate canadian pharmacy
mexican rx online: Meds From Mexico – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
canada online pharmacy: maple leaf pharmacy in canada – pharmacy canadian
india pharmacy top online pharmacy india п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
Svenska Pharma: apotek kolla recept – апотека
EFarmaciaIt: farmacia. – 20 italienisch
Papa Farma farmacia abierta cerca de mi ubicaciГіn actual 2 farma
https://svenskapharma.shop/# bäckenbälte apotek
Svenska Pharma: Svenska Pharma – Svenska Pharma
mГҐltidserstatter apotek: apotek 24h – apotek pГҐ nett gratis frakt
voltaren gel forte prezzo EFarmaciaIt EFarmaciaIt
sette vaksine apotek: Rask Apotek – saltvann apotek
Svenska Pharma: Svenska Pharma – apotek Г¶ppet trettondagen
https://efarmaciait.shop/# EFarmaciaIt
Papa Farma cabel plus opiniones Papa Farma
robilas orodispersibile: augmentin supposte adulti – EFarmaciaIt
Papa Farma Papa Farma Papa Farma
Svenska Pharma: Svenska Pharma – Svenska Pharma
farmasi espaГ±a catГЎlogo: Papa Farma – Papa Farma
https://papafarma.com/# Papa Farma
farmacia economica online EFarmaciaIt EFarmaciaIt
ledig stilling apotek: Rask Apotek – fingerskinne apotek
Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – teip apotek
apotek djur pulsoximeter apotek dmso apotek
Svenska Pharma: Svenska Pharma – Svenska Pharma
EFarmaciaIt: casa cares – EFarmaciaIt
https://efarmaciait.shop/# EFarmaciaIt
Svenska Pharma vilken välling är bäst apotek retinol
estreГ±imiento movicol: contraindicaciones cepillo dental elГ©ctrico – ozempic 0 25 comprar
EFarmaciaIt: poste francesi tracking – glicerina prezzo
farmacia carrГЁ EFarmaciaIt EFarmaciaIt
EFarmaciaIt: vermox in gravidanza forum – cosa serve ovixan crema
Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – Rask Apotek
http://papafarma.com/# Papa Farma
rosmarin olje apotek skin tag remover apotek allergitest apotek
EFarmaciaIt: EFarmaciaIt – EFarmaciaIt
Papa Farma: farmacia abierta madrid – Papa Farma
crestor 10 mg prezzo EFarmaciaIt dr max recensioni trustpilot
EFarmaciaIt: EFarmaciaIt – EFarmaciaIt
https://papafarma.com/# diprogenta crema para picaduras
sura uppstГ¶tningar hjГ¤rtat: Svenska Pharma – apotek Г¶ppettider sГ¶ndag
mint gravid kostar medicin till barn Svenska Pharma
Rask Apotek: elektrisk neglefil apotek – vaksine apotek
farmacia online gastos envio gratis oral b io cabezales farmacia burgos cerca de mi
EFarmaciaIt: treparin 250 prezzo – ozempic vendita online
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
aptoheke medikamente auf rechnung online apotheke gГјnstig
Pharma Jetzt: Pharma Jetzt – PharmaJetzt
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
medikamenten preisvergleich: Pharma Jetzt – Pharma Jetzt
pharmacie de garde nuit marseille: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
Medicijn Punt apotheek producten MedicijnPunt
http://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
http://pharmajetzt.com/# die gГјnstigste online apotheke
MedicijnPunt: Medicijn Punt – europese apotheek
jcm pharmacy tadacip: kroger pharmacy online – correct rx pharmacy
medicijn online bestellen pil online bestellen MedicijnPunt
shopi pharma: Pharma Confiance – contact ghd
medicatie apotheek: MedicijnPunt – Medicijn Punt
Pharma Connect USA spironolactone in house pharmacy Pharma Connect USA
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# lamisil boots pharmacy
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Connect USA: cobix generic celebrex pharmacy – PharmaConnectUSA