Doctrine of Basic Structure

  • The Doctrine of Basic Structure states that the Constitution of India has some basic features that can’t be altered or wiped out through amendments by the parliament.
  • The basic features are not specified by the Judiciary and it is considered that federalism, democracy, secularism, independence of the judiciary, etc. are some basic features of the Indian Constitution.
  • Landmark casesShankari Prasad vs. Union of India 

It was claimed that the amendment that violates the fundamental rights of the citizens is not conceded by Article 13.

  • However, in case Golak Nath vs. the State of Punjab, the Supreme Court affirmed a new thought to see the powers of parliament that it can’t alter Part III of the constitution i.e Fundamental rights.
  • In Keshavanada Bharti vs. the State of Kerala the court held that the parliament cannot amend or disturb the basic structure of the Constitution. It was held that, however, the parliament has the power to amend the constitution and not to rewrite the constitution.

Doctrine of Harmonious Construction

  • When there is a dispute among two or more acts or two or more parts of an act then the doctrine of harmonious construction applies.
  • According to this law, a statute should be read as a whole and one provision of the Act should be formed with relating to other provisions to make a harmonious enactment of the whole act and to remove any discrepancy or repugnancy.
  • It brings harmony between the various lists referred to in Schedule 7 of the constitution. 

(Lists of Legislation: – Union list, State list, and Concurrent list).

  • In the landmark judgment of CIT VS. HINDUSTAN BULK CARRIERS (2003)3 SCC 57 the Supreme Court laid down five principles of rule of harmonious construction:-
  1. The courts must avoid a clash on opposing provisions and they must interpret to harmonize them.
  2. The provision of two sections respectively cannot overcome each other except the court, despite all its effort, is unable to reconcile their differences.
  3. When it is difficult to reconcile the distinctions in the contradicting provision, the courts must interpret them so that effect is given to both the provisions as much as possible.
  4. The courts need to consider that, the interpretation that makes the provisions ambiguous or worthless is not harmonious construction.
  5. To harmonize is not to destroy any statutory provision or to make it pointless.

Also Read: Doctrines of Indian Constitution [Part-1]

Doctrine of Laches

  • The term “Laches” means “Delay”. This doctrine is based on the rule that “equity aids the vigilant and not those who slumber on their rights”.
  • It states that a legal right or claim will not be permitted if a long delay in affirming the right or claim has prejudiced the adverse party. Anyone who claims remedy must come within a reasonable time before the court.
  • Fundamental rights cannot be denied under Article 32 based on delay as it is unjustified. It is necessary for the development of the individual.
  • In case Ravindra Jain vs UOI, the supreme court stated that on the ground of unreasonable delay, the remedy under article 32 can be denied. However, there has been no case to override the above-mentioned case law by the Supreme Court order.

Doctrine of Judicial Review

  • The power of Judicial Review comes from the Constitution of India under Article 13.
  • This doctrine is evoked to protect and enforce the fundamental rights guaranteed in Part III of the Constitution.
  • The Parliament and the state legislatures are prohibited from making laws that violate or abridge the fundamental rights provided to the citizens of the country under Article 13 of the constitution.
  • The judicial review ensures the protection of the fundamental rights and considers any law “inconsistent with or in derogation of the fundamental rights” as void.
  • The Doctrine of Judicial Review applies by the Supreme Court while striking down of Section 66A of the IT Act as it was against the Fundamental Rights guaranteed by the constitution.

Doctrine of Waiver

  • This doctrine states that a person who is entitled to any right or privilege can abandon the privilege if done intentionally.
  • It acts on the presumption that the man is the best judge of his interest under any legal liability, and he has the knowledge while willfully giving up privilege.
  • In case Behram vs. the State of Maharashtra the court states that the fundamental rights were not kept only for individual benefit but for the general public and therefore the doctrine of waiver not applied to fundamental rights.

-Mohit Goyal
Associate at Law Offices of Kr. Vivek Tanwar, Advocate & Associates

44 Replies to “Doctrines of Indian Constitution [Part-2]”

  1. by RobertHip 4 months ago

    They have strong partnerships with pharmacies around the world.
    lisinopril side effects in elderly
    Clean, well-organized, and easy to navigate.

  2. by LorenzoREP 4 months ago

    They’ve revolutionized international pharmaceutical care.
    can you get cheap cytotec without dr prescription
    Offering a global touch with every service.

  3. by Edgargex 4 days ago

    arnica 7 ch: tadalafil generique – faire une analyse d’urine sans ordonnance

  4. by MichaelThemy 3 days ago

    http://zorgpakket.com/# medicijn online bestellen

  5. by Williamtheld 3 days ago

    https://tryggmed.com/# sopp i huden apotek

  6. by Kennethfrugs 3 days ago

    borsyra pulver apotek: apotekk – gripe water apotek

  7. by AltonWasia 3 days ago

    vattenreningstabletter apotek: Snabb Apoteket – Г¶ronproppar apotek

  8. by ScottVew 2 days ago

    apotheek producten medicatie bestellen medicatie bestellen apotheek

  9. by MichaelThemy 2 days ago

    https://zorgpakket.shop/# medicijnen bestellen zonder recept

  10. by Kennethfrugs 2 days ago

    resepter apotek: Trygg Med – fatle til arm apotek

  11. by AltonWasia 2 days ago

    pipetter apotek: TryggMed – influensavaksine 2021 apotek 1

  12. by ScottVew 2 days ago

    schampo mot svamp på kroppen Snabb Apoteket apotek knäskydd

  13. by MichaelThemy 2 days ago

    https://snabbapoteket.shop/# självtest apotek

  14. by Williamtheld 2 days ago

    https://zorgpakket.com/# apotheek nl online

  15. by Kennethfrugs 2 days ago

    collagen shot apotek: apotek sykehuset – hГҐrolje apotek

  16. by AltonWasia 2 days ago

    barn bh: billigt apotek – apotek inloggning

  17. by MichaelThemy 2 days ago

    https://snabbapoteket.com/# p piller pris

  18. by ScottVew 2 days ago

    apotek knäskydd Snabb Apoteket blåbär gravid

  19. by Kennethfrugs 2 days ago

    eteriske oljer apotek: fast grГёnnsГҐpe apotek – apotek.

  20. by AltonWasia 2 days ago

    rosenrot apotek: SnabbApoteket – hГҐllningssele apotek

  21. by MichaelThemy 2 days ago

    http://zorgpakket.com/# medicatie aanvragen

  22. by ScottVew 2 days ago

    apotek online snabb leverans SnabbApoteket ta blodtryck apotek

  23. by Williamtheld 2 days ago

    http://snabbapoteket.com/# snacks när man är sjuk

  24. by Kennethfrugs 1 day ago

    tandblekning apotek: apotek helgГ¶ppet – enbГ¤rsolja apotek

  25. by MichaelThemy 1 day ago

    http://zorgpakket.com/# de online apotheek

  26. by AltonWasia 1 day ago

    apteka internetowa holandia: Medicijn Punt – belgie apotheek online

  27. by Kennethfrugs 1 day ago

    slankepiller apotek: teknisk sprit apotek – fordГёyelsesenzymer apotek

  28. by MichaelThemy 1 day ago

    http://tryggmed.com/# munnbind tøy apotek

  29. by AltonWasia 1 day ago

    online medicijnen bestellen met recept: apotheek on line – apotheek nl online

  30. by ScottVew 22 hours ago

    selvtest korona apotek Trygg Med arnica krem apotek

  31. by Williamtheld 22 hours ago

    https://snabbapoteket.shop/# olika apotek på nätet

  32. by Kennethfrugs 20 hours ago

    apotek paracetamol: deodorant barn 7 Г¤r – Г¶rter naturens eget apotek

  33. by LewisLig 17 hours ago

    online shopping pharmacy india: top 10 online pharmacy in india – india online pharmacy

  34. by DavidPet 14 hours ago

    sildenafil citrate pharmacy grocery store pharmacy remote consultation online pharmacy

  35. by BobbyKeype 13 hours ago

    top 10 online pharmacy in india: top 10 pharmacies in india – best online pharmacy india

  36. by Robertfum 13 hours ago

    http://expresscarerx.org/# lisinopril wal-mart pharmacy

  37. by VernonMom 10 hours ago

    https://indiamedshub.com/# Online medicine order

  38. by DavidPet 8 hours ago

    indian pharmacies safe india online pharmacy indianpharmacy com

  39. by BobbyKeype 8 hours ago

    MediMexicoRx: get viagra without prescription from mexico – buy cheap meds from a mexican pharmacy

  40. by Robertfum 7 hours ago

    https://expresscarerx.online/# cialis online review online pharmacy

  41. by LewisLig 6 hours ago

    antabuse online pharmacy: viagra uk online pharmacy – Oxytrol

  42. by BobbyKeype 2 hours ago

    viagra pills from mexico: trusted mexico pharmacy with US shipping – sildenafil mexico online

  43. by Robertfum 2 hours ago

    http://medimexicorx.com/# mexican drugstore online

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.