.
Introduction
The rise of cryptocurrency has revolutionized the financial world, enabling peer-to-peer transactions, decentralizing monetary control, and offering a new form of digital asset that transcends national boundaries. From the pioneering Bitcoin launched in 2009 to the surge of altcoins and non-fungible tokens (NFTs), the crypto ecosystem has grown into a multitrillion-dollar industry. However, this rapid growth comes with significant legal and regulatory challenges. Fraudulent schemes, market manipulation, and regulatory uncertainty pose serious risks to consumers and governments alike. As we navigate this digital frontier, understanding the intersection of cryptocurrency and the law becomes not only essential but urgent.
I. Understanding Cryptocurrency and Its Legal Challenges
At its core, cryptocurrency is a digital asset that uses cryptography for secure transactions and operates on a decentralized network called blockchain. This decentralization is both its strength and its greatest legal complication. Unlike traditional financial systems that operate under centralized institutions like banks or governments, cryptocurrencies are not regulated by any single authority. This raises several legal issues regarding ownership, accountability, and enforceability of laws.
Key legal challenges surrounding cryptocurrency include
- Lack of consistent definitions: Is cryptocurrency a currency, a commodity, property, or a security? The answer varies by jurisdiction and even within the same country.
- Jurisdictional uncertainty: With no geographical boundaries, it’s often unclear which country’s laws apply to specific crypto transactions.
- Regulatory lag: Laws are typically reactive, not proactive, and regulators struggle to keep pace with the rapid technological developments in the crypto space.
II. The Global Regulatory Landscape
Regulation of cryptocurrency varies significantly around the world, resulting in a fragmented global framework. Some countries have embraced digital assets with open arms, while others have taken a cautious or even hostile approach.
1. United States
In the U.S., cryptocurrency regulation is divided among several agencies:
- The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) classifies certain cryptocurrencies as securities, particularly when sold through Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs).
- The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) considers Bitcoin and Ethereum as commodities.
- The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) treats crypto as property for tax purposes. This patchwork approach creates legal confusion and increases the compliance burden for companies and investors.
2. European Union
The EU is moving toward more consistent regulation through the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation, which aims to standardize rules across member states. MiCA requires issuers of crypto-assets and service providers to follow transparency, licensing, and consumer protection norms. It’s a landmark attempt to bring coherence and legal certainty to the European crypto market.
3. China and India
China has imposed a complete ban on cryptocurrency trading and mining, citing concerns over financial stability, energy consumption, and capital outflows. India, on the other hand, has oscillated in its approach—considering a ban at one point, but now imposing strict taxation, including a 30% tax on crypto gains and 1% TDS on transactions, signaling a grudging acceptance.
4. El Salvador
In stark contrast, El Salvador became the first country to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender, demonstrating the diverse regulatory experiments taking place globally.
III. Cryptocurrency Fraud: A Growing Concern
Cryptocurrency’s anonymous and irreversible nature makes it an attractive target for fraudsters. The scale and variety of crypto-related scams have surged, leading to billions in losses globally.
1. Ponzi Schemes and Rug Pulls
These involve fake or deceptive projects that promise high returns to investors. In a rug pull, developers suddenly withdraw all funds and disappear, leaving investors with worthless tokens. A notable example is the Squid Game Token, which soared in price before crashing to zero when developers exited.
2. Hacking and Phishing
Crypto exchanges and wallets have become prime targets for cybercriminals. In 2022 alone, over $3 billion was stolen through hacks. Phishing attacks targeting individuals’ private keys or seed phrases are also rampant, often leaving victims without recourse.
3. Pump and Dump Schemes
Here, bad actors artificially inflate the value of a token through misleading information, then sell off their holdings, causing prices to plummet and resulting in huge losses for retail investors.
4. Fake ICOs and NFTs
Some developers raise capital through ICOs or sell NFTs for projects that never materialize. Without proper legal oversight, investors have little protection or avenues for redress.
V. The Future of Cryptocurrency Law: Finding a Balance
As the crypto space continues to grow and evolve, governments must find a balance between innovation and protection. Over-regulation risks stifling innovation and pushing projects underground, while under-regulation invites fraud and systemic risk.
Key steps toward effective legal regulation include:
- Unified legal definitions and frameworks: Clear categorization of crypto-assets can help in drafting relevant laws.
- Mandatory KYC/AML norms: Enforcing identity verification and anti-money laundering practices for exchanges and wallets.
- International cooperation: Coordinated efforts between countries to track and prosecute crypto crimes.
- Public awareness and education: Empowering users to recognize and avoid scams.
Is Cryptocurrency Legal in India?
Cryptocurrency is not illegal in India, but it is also not recognized as legal tender. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) had initially imposed a banking ban on crypto transactions in 2018, which was later struck down by the Supreme Court in Internet and Mobile Association of India v. RBI (2020).
While trading, investing, and holding cryptocurrency is permitted, the lack of a dedicated legal framework means offenses are currently being tackled using general laws such as the IPC, the Information Technology Act, 2000, and provisions under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).
Common Crypto-Related Frauds and IPC Provisions
1. Cheating (Section 415 & 420 IPC)
Crypto fraud often involves cheating investors through fake investment schemes or false promises of high returns.
- Section 415 IPC: Defines cheating as deceitfully inducing someone to deliver property or do something they wouldn’t have done otherwise.
- Section 420 IPC: Deals with cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property—a common charge in crypto scams.
Example: A fake crypto exchange promising high ROI, collecting funds, and then vanishing can attract Section 420 IPC.
2. Criminal Breach of Trust (Section 405 & 406 IPC)
If someone is entrusted with cryptocurrency and dishonestly misappropriates it, this amounts to criminal breach of trust.
- Section 405 IPC: Defines the offense.
- Section 406 IPC: Provides punishment—up to 3 years and/or fine.
Example: A crypto wallet custodian or intermediary misusing client funds.
3. Forgery and False Documentation (Sections 465, 468, 471 IPC)
Creating fake crypto tokens, wallets, or websites to deceive users can be charged under forgery-related offenses.
- Section 465: Punishes forgery.
- Section 468: Forgery for cheating.
- Section 471: Using forged documents as genuine.
4. Criminal Conspiracy (Section 120B IPC)
Multiple individuals working together to execute a large-scale crypto scam can be booked under criminal conspiracy.
Example: Founders of a fraudulent token project collaborating to siphon off investor money.
5. Dishonest Misappropriation (Section 403 IPC)
If someone dishonestly takes or uses cryptocurrency belonging to another, they may be booked under Section 403.
Other Relevant Laws in Crypto Offenses
Information Technology Act, 2000
- Section 66D: Punishes cheating by personation using computer resources.
- Section 43 & 66: Deal with unauthorized access and damage to computer systems.
These are often used when phishing, hacking, or unauthorized transfers of crypto are involved.
Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), 2002
- Crypto is increasingly being used for money laundering. The Finance Ministry (2023) brought Virtual Digital Assets (VDAs) under the PMLA.
- Any suspicious crypto transaction can now attract PMLA charges, requiring reporting by crypto exchanges and platforms.
Conclusion
Cryptocurrency represents one of the most disruptive financial innovations of our time, offering both tremendous potential and substantial legal challenges. As digital assets continue to integrate into mainstream finance, the need for clear, adaptive, and enforceable legal frameworks becomes paramount. Regulation must walk the tightrope—encouraging innovation while protecting investors, preventing fraud, and ensuring the integrity of financial systems. The coming decade will be crucial in shaping the legal foundation of the crypto economy.
contributed by: TANISHA ARORA (INTERN)