Rajinder da Dhaba, a well-known eatery in Delhi’s Safdarjung Enclave, is currently under scrutiny by the National Green Tribunal (NGT). This follows a complaint from the Safdarjung Enclave AB Block Market Welfare Association, which alleges that the establishment is violating environmental regulations and contributing to noise and air pollution. In response, the NGT has instructed the Delhi Pollution Control Committee to inspect the area for potential violations.

Constitutional and legislative mandate

In response to the Stockholm Declaration, 1972, a landmark event in the history of international environmental law, India took steps to incorporate environmental protection principles into its legal framework. This led to the insertion of two important articles in the Indian Constitution in 1976:

Article 48-A: This article directs the State to endeavor to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard forests and wildlife.

Article 51-A(g): This clause imposes a fundamental duty on every citizen of India to protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers, and wildlife, and to have compassion for living creatures.

The combined impact of Articles 48-A and 51-A(g) of the Indian Constitution signifies a dual constitutional responsibility for both the State and its citizens to protect, preserve, and enhance India’s environmental conditions.

Apart from the constitutional mandate to protect and improve the environmental conditions, there are a series of legislations available on the subject but more relevant legislations for our purpose are the Forest [Conservation] Act, 1980; the Water [Prevention and Control of Pollution] Act, 1974; the Wildlife [Protection] Act, 1972; the Environment [Protection] Act, 1986;the Air[Prevention and Control of Pollution] Act, 1981; the National Environment Tribunal Act, 1995; the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010; the Biological Diversity Act, 2002 and the Hazardous Wastes [Management and Handling] Amendment Rules, 2003 etc.

The Water [Prevention and Control of Pollution] Act, 1974 provides for the prevention and control of water pollution and the maintaining or resorting of the integrity of water. This Act prohibits any poisonous, noxious or polluting material from entering into any source, stream or well.

The Air [Prevention and Control of Pollution] Act, 1981 has been designed to prevent, control and abatement of air pollution in the climate. Main sources of air pollution are industries, factories, automobiles, domestic fires and vehicles etc.

The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 was enacted following the Bhopal Gas Tragedy to prevent and control environmental pollution and improve environmental quality. It defines “environment” broadly to include water, air, land, and the interrelationships between these elements and all living beings, including plants, animals, and micro-organisms.

There is no deficiency of available legislations on environmental protection in India but enforcement of these legislations has been far from satisfactory. There is urgent need for the effective, successful and well–organized enforcement of the Constitutional mandate and other environmental legislations or laws in India.

Judicial involvement

In the Sri Ram Food and Fertilizer case [M.C. Mehta v. Union of India AIR 1987 SC 1086.], following a major gas leak in Bhopal, the Supreme Court ruled that enterprises engaged in hazardous activities bear absolute liability for any harm caused by accidents related to their operations. This means they are solely responsible for compensating all affected parties, without any exemptions, emphasizing strict accountability for incidents involving dangerous substances.

In the Dehradun Valley case [Rural Litigation and Entitlement Kendra v. State of Uttar Pradesh AIR 1985 SC 652.], 12 haphazard and dangerous limestone quarrying in the Missouri Mountain range of the Himalayas, dynamite eroding hills, and thousands of acres of limestone quarries disrupted the valley’s hydrological system. The Apex Court ordered the closing of limestone quarrying in the hills and observed: “It will undoubtedly cause hardship to them, but it is a value that has to be compensated for protecting and protecting people’s right to live in a clean and healthy environment with minimal disturbance of the ecological balance.”

In Subba Rao v. State of Himachal Pradesh [AIR 1989 SC 171.], the Supreme Court ordered the closure of a bone factory due to its pollution causing significant discomfort to people due to foul odors. The Court emphasized that no business should operate at the expense of public health.

Similarly, to preserve the environment and control pollution near tourist resorts in Badkhal and Surajkund, the Supreme Court directed the cessation of mining activities within a two-kilometer radius of these areas.

In Almitra H. Patel v. Union of India [AIR 2000 SC 1256], the Supreme Court reiterated the observations made in Wadehra’s case [B.L. Wadehra v. Union of India AIR 1996 SC 2969.]:

“The capital of India, Delhi is an old and well–known city which is one of the polluted cities in the world. e authorities and government are responsible for pollution control and environmental protection is not able to provide natural clean and healthy environment to the residents of Delhi. e ambient air is so polluted that it is difficult for humans to breathe. More and more people are suffering from respiratory diseases and throat infections. e Yamuna River, the main source of drinking water supply, is a free dumping place for untreated sewerage and industrial effluents. Apart from air and water pollution, the city is almost an open dustbin. Garbage scattered all over Delhi is a common sight.”

The “polluter pays principle” holds that enterprises responsible for pollution should bear the financial costs of preventing damage and cleaning up. This principle, recognized by the Supreme Court, extends beyond compensating victims to include restoring the environment. It imposes absolute liability on polluters, increasing their financial responsibility to cover both compensation for victims and the costs of ecosystem restoration. This approach aligns with sustainable development goals, ensuring that environmental damage is mitigated and repaired by those responsible for causing it.

Enforcement of Environmental laws : Problems and Challenges

In recent years, there has been a notable increase in cases related to environmental pollution, ecological destruction, and disputes over natural resources appearing before the Courts. These cases often require specialized environmental expertise and scientific knowledge to inform judicial decisions effectively.

The existing setup in ordinary Criminal Courts, which handle cases under laws such as the Water Act, the Air Act, and the Environment (Protection) Act, frequently encounters challenges. Cases often languish without reaching conclusion due to heavy caseloads or insufficient understanding of environmental issues among court personnel. Moreover, decisions made by authorities under these environmental laws are frequently contested by industries in court, leading to prolonged legal procedures that can span many years.

During these extended legal battles, interim orders are sometimes issued that hinder the effective implementation of regulatory measures by environmental officers. This procedural delay further complicates efforts to address and mitigate environmental damage promptly.

Given these complexities, there is a growing recognition of the need for specialized Environment Courts equipped with high-level scientific and technical expertise. Such specialized courts would be better equipped to handle complex environmental cases efficiently, ensuring more informed and expedient judicial decisions that prioritize environmental protection and sustainable development.

Conclusion

To enhance enforcement of environmental laws, establishing Environment Courts with one judge and two technical experts in Environmental Science and Ecology is crucial. These courts should adopt summary proceedings for swift case resolution, initially at state and national levels, potentially expanding to district levels as needed. Limiting appeals to discourage prolonged litigation is advisable.

Public Interest Litigation (PIL) has expanded the courts’ jurisdiction, allowing them to direct administrative actions for environmental improvement. However, effective environmental protection requires bottom-up social awareness, not just top-down legislation. To educate the public, the Supreme Court has advocated displaying environmental awareness slides in regional languages at cinemas and on television free of cost. Additionally, environmental studies should become a mandatory subject in schools and colleges to foster widespread awareness.

Ultimately, safeguarding the environment and maintaining ecological balance is a shared responsibility outlined in Article 51-A(g) of the Indian Constitution, applicable to every individual, organization, and corporation.

111 Replies to “Challenges Of Convictions Against Environmental Violations”

  1. by PatrickSpone 1 week ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm

  2. by Alfonsoonera 1 week ago

    CrestorPharm: rosuvastatin allergic reaction – Safe online pharmacy for Crestor

  3. by BillySiz 1 week ago

    Semaglu Pharm: Order Rybelsus discreetly – SemagluPharm

  4. by AlbertoNeire 1 week ago

    CrestorPharm [url=https://crestorpharm.com/#]Crestor Pharm[/url] Crestor Pharm

  5. by JamesMok 1 week ago

    https://prednipharm.shop/# prednisone 10 mg brand name

  6. by Alfonsoonera 1 week ago

    Lipi Pharm: Affordable Lipitor alternatives USA – atorvastatin and cranberry juice

  7. by AlbertoNeire 1 week ago

    Discreet shipping for Lipitor [url=https://lipipharm.shop/#]Online statin drugs no doctor visit[/url] LipiPharm

  8. by Alfonsoonera 1 week ago

    No doctor visit required statins: CrestorPharm – difference between atorvastatin and rosuvastatin

  9. by BillySiz 1 week ago

    Online pharmacy Rybelsus: SemagluPharm – SemagluPharm

  10. by AlbertoNeire 1 week ago

    Rybelsus for blood sugar control [url=http://semaglupharm.com/#]Order Rybelsus discreetly[/url] SemagluPharm

  11. by Alfonsoonera 1 week ago

    Lipi Pharm: Lipi Pharm – does atorvastatin help you lose weight

  12. by BillySiz 1 week ago

    Lipi Pharm: Cheap Lipitor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg – Safe atorvastatin purchase without RX

  13. by AlbertoNeire 1 week ago

    crestor vs lipitor dosage [url=https://crestorpharm.com/#]CrestorPharm[/url] CrestorPharm

  14. by Alfonsoonera 1 week ago

    is 40 mg of rosuvastatin a high dose: is lipitor better than crestor – CrestorPharm

  15. by AlbertoNeire 7 days ago

    SemagluPharm [url=https://semaglupharm.shop/#]SemagluPharm[/url] SemagluPharm

  16. by Alfonsoonera 7 days ago

    switching from pravastatin to rosuvastatin: Buy statins online discreet shipping – Crestor Pharm

  17. by BillySiz 7 days ago

    Predni Pharm: medicine prednisone 5mg – prednisone online for sale

  18. by AlbertoNeire 7 days ago

    USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery [url=http://lipipharm.com/#]LipiPharm[/url] Lipi Pharm

  19. by Alfonsoonera 7 days ago

    zetia vs rosuvastatin: Crestor Pharm – rosuvastatin and weight loss

  20. by AlbertoNeire 6 days ago

    Crestor Pharm [url=http://crestorpharm.com/#]what is the most common side effect of crestor?[/url] what is the side effects of crestor

  21. by Alfonsoonera 6 days ago

    prednisone 15 mg tablet: Predni Pharm – PredniPharm

  22. by JamesMok 6 days ago

    https://semaglupharm.com/# can you take rybelsus and ozempic together

  23. by BillySiz 6 days ago

    Lipi Pharm: USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery – stopping lipitor in elderly

  24. by AlbertoNeire 6 days ago

    Predni Pharm [url=http://prednipharm.com/#]PredniPharm[/url] PredniPharm

  25. by Alfonsoonera 6 days ago

    by prednisone w not prescription: Predni Pharm – prednisone 20mg price

  26. by BillySiz 6 days ago

    Crestor mail order USA: Crestor Pharm – Affordable cholesterol-lowering pills

  27. by AlbertoNeire 6 days ago

    pancreatitis semaglutide [url=http://semaglupharm.com/#]Rybelsus 3mg 7mg 14mg[/url] Semaglu Pharm

  28. by Alfonsoonera 6 days ago

    prednisone uk over the counter: PredniPharm – generic prednisone 10mg

  29. by BillySiz 6 days ago

    Semaglu Pharm: Semaglu Pharm – SemagluPharm

  30. by JamesMok 6 days ago

    http://lipipharm.com/# atorvastatin 20

  31. by AlbertoNeire 6 days ago

    prednisone 10mg buy online [url=http://prednipharm.com/#]prednisone buy[/url] PredniPharm

  32. by Alfonsoonera 6 days ago

    SemagluPharm: does medicare cover rybelsus – what company makes rybelsus

  33. by BillySiz 5 days ago

    PredniPharm: PredniPharm – Predni Pharm

  34. by AlbertoNeire 5 days ago

    what time of day is the best time to take rosuvastatin [url=https://crestorpharm.com/#]rosuvastatin 20 mg[/url] Crestor Pharm

  35. by Alfonsoonera 5 days ago

    20 mg of prednisone: Predni Pharm – PredniPharm

  36. by BillySiz 5 days ago

    is crestor bad for you: Crestor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg online – CrestorPharm

  37. by AlbertoNeire 5 days ago

    Online pharmacy Rybelsus [url=https://semaglupharm.com/#]Safe delivery in the US[/url] Semaglu Pharm

  38. by Alfonsoonera 5 days ago

    CrestorPharm: Online statin therapy without RX – п»їBuy Crestor without prescription

  39. by Roberttooff 5 days ago

    India Pharm Global: india pharmacy mail order – India Pharm Global

  40. by Samuelepize 5 days ago

    Meds From Mexico [url=http://medsfrommexico.com/#]best online pharmacies in mexico[/url] purple pharmacy mexico price list

  41. by MichelLiard 5 days ago

    canadian pharmacy meds review: Canada Pharm Global – my canadian pharmacy reviews

  42. by Roberttooff 5 days ago

    safe canadian pharmacies: canadian pharmacy world – canadian drugs online

  43. by JamesRor 5 days ago

    http://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico

  44. by Samuelepize 5 days ago

    best canadian pharmacy [url=https://canadapharmglobal.shop/#]Canada Pharm Global[/url] thecanadianpharmacy

  45. by MichelLiard 5 days ago

    top online pharmacy india: indian pharmacy paypal – top online pharmacy india

  46. by Roberttooff 5 days ago

    Meds From Mexico: Meds From Mexico – Meds From Mexico

  47. by Samuelepize 4 days ago

    mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://medsfrommexico.shop/#]purple pharmacy mexico price list[/url] mexican pharmaceuticals online

  48. by MichelLiard 4 days ago

    India Pharm Global: world pharmacy india – India Pharm Global

  49. by JamesRor 4 days ago

    http://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global

  50. by Roberttooff 4 days ago

    real canadian pharmacy: Canada Pharm Global – www canadianonlinepharmacy

  51. by Samuelepize 4 days ago

    India Pharm Global [url=http://indiapharmglobal.com/#]top online pharmacy india[/url] India Pharm Global

  52. by MichelLiard 4 days ago

    vipps approved canadian online pharmacy: canadian medications – onlinepharmaciescanada com

  53. by Roberttooff 4 days ago

    best rated canadian pharmacy: adderall canadian pharmacy – certified canadian international pharmacy

  54. by MichelLiard 4 days ago

    India Pharm Global: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global

  55. by Samuelepize 4 days ago

    buying prescription drugs in mexico [url=http://medsfrommexico.com/#]Meds From Mexico[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  56. by JamesRor 4 days ago

    https://medsfrommexico.com/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  57. by MichelLiard 4 days ago

    buying prescription drugs in mexico online: Meds From Mexico – mexican mail order pharmacies

  58. by Roberttooff 4 days ago

    medication from mexico pharmacy: Meds From Mexico – Meds From Mexico

  59. by Samuelepize 4 days ago

    canadian pharmacy scam [url=https://canadapharmglobal.shop/#]Canada Pharm Global[/url] canadian pharmacy scam

  60. by MichelLiard 4 days ago

    canadian king pharmacy: safe canadian pharmacy – canadian pharmacy scam

  61. by Roberttooff 4 days ago

    Online medicine home delivery: reputable indian pharmacies – India Pharm Global

  62. by Samuelepize 4 days ago

    online pharmacy india [url=http://indiapharmglobal.com/#]India Pharm Global[/url] India Pharm Global

  63. by JamesRor 3 days ago

    https://canadapharmglobal.shop/# canadian pharmacy ltd

  64. by MichelLiard 3 days ago

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican rx online – buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  65. by Roberttooff 3 days ago

    safe canadian pharmacy: certified canadian pharmacy – canada cloud pharmacy

  66. by Samuelepize 3 days ago

    my canadian pharmacy reviews [url=https://canadapharmglobal.shop/#]Canada Pharm Global[/url] canada rx pharmacy

  67. by MichelLiard 3 days ago

    canadian drugs pharmacy: best canadian online pharmacy – reputable canadian online pharmacies

  68. by Roberttooff 3 days ago

    canadian pharmacy victoza: Canada Pharm Global – online canadian drugstore

  69. by Williamtax 3 days ago

    apotek teip: levere tilbake medisiner pГҐ apotek – flass sjampo apotek

  70. by JosephDrymn 3 days ago

    farmacia apotek [url=http://raskapotek.com/#]Rask Apotek[/url] tidlig graviditetstest apotek

  71. by ClintonElade 3 days ago

    antikroppstest apotek: apotek piercing – Svenska Pharma

  72. by Williamtax 3 days ago

    ortopedia shop recensioni: EFarmaciaIt – EFarmaciaIt

  73. by JosephDrymn 3 days ago

    Rask Apotek [url=https://raskapotek.com/#]shampoo for fett hГҐr apotek[/url] Rask Apotek

  74. by ClintonElade 3 days ago

    midlertidig fylling apotek: kontaktlinser apotek – fullmakt til apotek

  75. by Williamtax 2 days ago

    toallitas dodot oferta: parafarmacia online espaГ±a – Papa Farma

  76. by JosephDrymn 2 days ago

    Papa Farma [url=http://papafarma.com/#]tadalafilo 5 mg comprar online[/url] Papa Farma

  77. by ClintonElade 2 days ago

    ШµЩЉШЇЩ„ЩЉШ© Ш§Щ„ШіЩ€ЩЉШЇ: Svenska Pharma – Svenska Pharma

  78. by Williamtax 2 days ago

    kjГёpe medisin pГҐ nett: aporek – Гёyemaske apotek

  79. by RobertBip 2 days ago

    https://raskapotek.com/# legevendelrot apotek

  80. by JosephDrymn 2 days ago

    Papa Farma [url=https://papafarma.shop/#]Papa Farma[/url] cabezales oral b niГ±os

  81. by Williamtax 2 days ago

    Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – Rask Apotek

  82. by JosephDrymn 2 days ago

    snabb hemleverans apotek [url=https://svenskapharma.shop/#]bh billigt[/url] tissla tassla apotek

  83. by ClintonElade 2 days ago

    Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – legemidler pГҐ nett

  84. by Williamtax 2 days ago

    tudca kГ¶pa: Svenska Pharma – apotek dk

  85. by JosephDrymn 2 days ago

    EFarmaciaIt [url=https://efarmaciait.com/#]EFarmaciaIt[/url] eutirox a cosa serve

  86. by Williamtax 2 days ago

    pastiglie xanax: EFarmaciaIt – lasix prezzo senza ricetta

  87. by JosephDrymn 1 day ago

    apotek deo [url=http://svenskapharma.com/#]cetirizine apotek[/url] Svenska Pharma

  88. by ClintonElade 1 day ago

    droguerГ­a cerca de mi ubicaciГіn: viagra on line – elocom crema para que sirve

  89. by Williamtax 1 day ago

    Svenska Pharma: Svenska Pharma – Svenska Pharma

  90. by JosephDrymn 1 day ago

    Rask Apotek [url=http://raskapotek.com/#]Rask Apotek[/url] Rask Apotek

  91. by ClintonElade 1 day ago

    Papa Farma: Papa Farma – Papa Farma

  92. by Williamtax 1 day ago

    apotek pГҐ nett resept: Rask Apotek – Rask Apotek

  93. by JosephDrymn 21 hours ago

    massasjeolje apotek [url=https://raskapotek.com/#]sjampo mot flass apotek[/url] probiotika apotek

  94. by ClintonElade 19 hours ago

    cГіmo llegar a parque alcosa: Papa Farma – citrafleet genГ©rico

  95. by Williamtax 18 hours ago

    EFarmaciaIt: siti farmacia affidabili – EFarmaciaIt

  96. by JosephDrymn 14 hours ago

    alun apotek [url=http://raskapotek.com/#]Rask Apotek[/url] spoteket

  97. by ClintonElade 13 hours ago

    para que sirve vimovo: Papa Farma – Papa Farma

  98. by Williamtax 12 hours ago

    drospil pillola: brufen 600 farmacia online – EFarmaciaIt

  99. by JosephDrymn 8 hours ago

    Rask Apotek [url=https://raskapotek.com/#]Rask Apotek[/url] fjerne Гёrevoks apotek

  100. by Williamtax 5 hours ago

    apo: Rask Apotek – hurtigtest covid 19 apotek

  101. by RobertBip 3 hours ago

    https://raskapotek.com/# skylleflaske apotek

  102. by ClintonElade 2 hours ago

    gocce en: acido zeta dove si compra – EFarmaciaIt

  103. by Melvinhex 22 minutes ago

    PharmaConnectUSA: clomid uk pharmacy – valtrex pharmacy coupon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.