Tuka Ram & Anr V. State of Maharashtra

Facts

A minor girl was reportedly raped by two police officers on March 26, 1972, while they were holding her. In Maharashtra’s Desai Gunj Police Station, this occurrence occurred. In the context of Indian rape legislation, this case brought up a number of concerns, most notably the burden of proof and the consent question.

Judgment

The Sessions court held that the defendants were not guilty due to the voluntary consent of the victim. It was held that Mathura willingly gave her consent to the sexual intercourse as she was habituated to it. The Sessions judge has ruled that rape and sexual intercourse are different terms and cannot be used in the same case.

The case was then appealed in the Bombay High Court, which took note of all the findings in the trial conducted in the sessions court. The High Court has appreciated the observation made by a Sessions Judge that there’s a difference between rape and sexual intercourse. However, they forgot to point out that there’s a difference between passive submission and consent. The court then noted that the consent given to the accused was not voluntary and was made due to the threat of arrest by the police.

Later, the case was referred to the Supreme Court, where the accused were acquitted. The Court noted that the girl did not show signs of any resistance or injury and that her consent was voluntary. Also, the girl might have incited the police as she was habituated to sex. The Supreme Court of India has ruled that the sexual intercourse that was in question was not rape.

Changes brought upon the laws after this case

Due to the controversial nature of the verdict, which led to widespread protests and public outcry, India’s rape law was amended in 1986. During the time of the Mathura rape case, the rape laws in India were heavily biased towards rapists.

The main issue which was raised was about the concept of consent. Earlier it was very difficult for women to prove that they did not consent to sexual intercourse. After the judgment of this case, in 1983, the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act was passed, which brought various changes in the Indian rape law.

In 1983 Criminal Law Act, a new Section 114(A) of the Indian Evidence Act was inserted to enable courts to presume that the victim did not consent to the sexual intercourse if she was assaulted if she had said that she did not consent for the intercourse.

Subsections a, b, c, and d of Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code underwent various amendments made by the Criminal Law Amendment Act, 2013. This Act also adds the word “custodial rape” to the Indian Penal Code 1860 for offenses that are carried out when a victim is in custody.

Persons who violate Section 376(2) are subject to rigorous imprisonment for a term not less than ten years or for life with a fine. The burden of evidence always being with the victim was modified by the Act. When there has already been sexual activity, the onus of proof shifts to the accuser. The Indian Penal Code’s Section 228A forbids publishing the names of rape victims. as a result of the 2013 Criminal Law Amendments Act changes.

In India, the Mathura rape case, which provoked protracted demonstrations and widespread outrage, had a profound social and legal consequence. As a result, several sexual harassment statutes were established.

Adv. Khanak Sharma (D/1710/23)

4 Replies to “Judgment that shaped Rape laws in INDIA – MATHURA RAPE CASE”

  1. Wenn Sie nach den spannendsten Optionen suchen, werfen Sie einen Blick auf neue Casinos, die innovative
    Spiele und attraktive Bonusangebote bieten. Diese Plattformen bieten oftmals
    attraktive Boni und ein breites Spielangebot. Online Casinos ohne Verifizierung
    bieten Ihnen eine schnelle Registrierung und sofortige Einzahlungen. In der
    Welt des Online-Glücksspiels gewinnen Casinos ohne Verifizierung zunehmend an Beliebtheit.

    Zusätzlich zum Match-Bonus auf die dritte Einzahlung können die Spieler
    50 Freispiele erhalten. Wenn Spieler mindestens €50 einzahlen, erhalten sie einen 50% Match
    Bonus von 200 € und 50 Rolling Slots Freispiele. Wenn Spieler mindestens €50 einzahlen, erhalten sie
    einen 100% Match Bonus und 100 Rolling Slots Freispiele.
    Nachdem die qualifizierende Einzahlung getätigt wurde, erhält der Spieler die Möglichkeit, den Einzahlungsbonus und die Freispiele nacheinander im Profilbereich zu
    aktivieren. Zahlt daher jetzt einfach über Trustly dort ein und schon könnt Ihr ohne Verifizierung Online Casino
    Spiele spielen.
    Wer ohne Registrierung und KYC-Prüfung spielen möchte, findet
    dort eine legale Alternative. Unsere Erfahrung zeigt, dass deutsche Spieler
    dort legal spielen können, da diese Anbieter über eine europäische Konzession verfügen. Neben Spielautomaten könnt ihr auch das Casino Tischspiel Roulette spielen. Ihr zahlt einfach per
    PayPal ein und könnt direkt losspielen.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/izzi-casino-cashback-ihre-ruckerstattung-leicht-gemacht/

  2. One of the biggest drawcards of playing at an online casino is undoubtedly the Avantgarde Casino bonuses and promotions on offer.
    Avantgarde Casino offers a full suite of features for the discerning Aussie
    gambler looking for a top-notch online casino experience.

    Those games look and play so crisp, it’s like being
    in a real Vegas casino! They even have live dealer games if you’re after that
    real casino feel.
    Having overweight and obesity raises the risk of sleep apnea—night-time
    snoring and breathing difficulties—and sleep problems.

    Don’t overeat (especially heavy or fatty foods) or have large meals within three
    hours of bedtime. Large meals at night can also impact
    sleep quality. However, bright light at night can trick your brain into thinking it’s still waking time and make it more difficult to fall asleep.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/las-vegas-a-comprehensive-guide/

  3. We take a look at both how many games are offered,
    and how varied those games really are. To find a great casino, Australia online players should look for a whole range of factors when deciding whether it’s right for them.
    Use our reviews & rating guides to instantly compare EVERY Australian casino gaming site
    and find the best online casino for you. Casino Australia Online.net is one of the biggest websites for online casino
    comparison in Australia.
    This means that your deposit amount will be double to a maximum of $1.000.
    SSL protects all communications between your internet
    browser and the casino’s web server. It’s the thrill of real stakes that makes them so popular,
    and the potential for some serious winnings
    just adds to the excitement. Wherever you
    end up playing, remember to gamble responsibly and have fun! These could include deposit limits,
    time check-ins, or even self-exclusion periods, and we encourage you to take
    note of them.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/kingpin-crown-melbourne-casino-guide/

  4. online real casino paypal

    References:
    http://www.s-golflex.kr

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.